ARM Challenging Intel in the Server Market: An Overview
RISC vs. CISC Revisited
The RISC vs. CISC discussion is never ending. It started as soon as the first RISC CPUs entered the market in the mid eighties. Just six years ago, Anand reported that AMD's CTO, Fred Weber was claiming:
Fred said that the overhead of maintaining x86 compatibility was negligible, at the time around 10% of the die was the x86 decoder and that percentage would only shrink over time.
Just like Intel today, AMD claimed that the overhead of the complex x86 ISA was dwindling fast as the transistor budget grew exponentially with Moore's law. But the thing to remember is that high ranking managers will always make statements that fit their current strategy and vision. Most of the time there is some truth in it, but the subtleties and nuances of the story are the first victims in press releases and statements.
Now in 2014, it is good to put an end to all this discussion: the ISA is not a game changer, but it matters! AMD is now in a very good position to judge as it will develop x86 and ARM CPUs by the same team, lead by the same CPU architecture veteran. We listened carefully to what Jim Keller, the head of the AMD CPU architect team, had to say in the 4th minute of this YouTube video:
"The big fundamental thing is that ARMv8 ISA has more registers (32), a three operand ISA, and spends less transistors on decoding and dealing with the complexities of x86. That allows us to spend more transistors on performance... ARM gives us some inherent architectural efficiency."
You can debate until you drop, but there is no denying that the x86 ISA requires more pipeline stages and thus transistors to decode than any decent RISC ISA. As x86 instructions are variable length, fetching instructions is less efficient and requires more transistors. The instruction cache is also larger as you need to store pre-decode information. The back-end might deal with RISC-like micro-ops but as the end result must adhere to rules of the x86 ISA, thus transistors are spent on exception handling and condition codes.
It's true that the percentage of transistors spent on decoding has dwindled over the years. But the number of cores has increased significantly. As a result, the x86 tax is not imaginary.
Hardware Accelerators
While we feel that the ARMv8 ISA is definitely a competitive advantage for the ARM server SoCs, the hardware accelerators are a big mystery: we have no idea how large the performance or power advantage is in real software. It might be spectacular or it might be just another "offload works only in the rare case where all these conditions are met". Nevertheless, it is interesting to see how the ARM server SoC has many different integrated accelerators.
Most of them are the usual IPSec, TCP offloading engines, and Cryptographic accelerators. It will be interesting to see if the ARM ecosystem can offer more specialized devices that can really outperform the typical Intel offerings.
One IP block that got my attention was the the Regex accelerators of Cavium. Regular expression accelerators are specialized in pattern recognition and can be very useful for search engines, network security, and data analytics. That seems exactly what we need in the current killer apps. But the devil is in the details: it will need software support, and preferably on a wide scale.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/8776/arm-challinging-intel-in-the-server-market-an-overview (Wayback Machine).