Multi-Client Access - NAS Environment
We configured three of the HGST Deskstar NAS drives in a RAID-5 volume in the QNAP TS-EC1279U-SAS-RP. A CIFS share in the volume was subject to some IOMeter tests with access from up to 25 VMs simultaneously. The following four graphs show the total available bandwidth and the average response time while being subject to different types of workloads through IOMeter. IOMeter also reports various other metrics of interest such as maximum response time, read and write IOPS, separate read and write bandwidth figures etc. Some of the interesting aspects from our IOMeter benchmarking run are available here .
HGST Deskstar NAS 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - 100% Sequential Reads WD Red 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - 100% Sequential Reads WD Red Pro 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - 100% Sequential Reads Toshiba MG03ACA400 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - 100% Sequential Reads WD Se 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - 100% Sequential Reads Seagate Enterprise Capacity v4 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - 100% Sequential Reads Seagate NAS HDD 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - 100% Sequential Reads Seagate Terascale SED 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - 100% Sequential Reads WD Re 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - 100% Sequential Reads Seagate Constellation ES.3 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - 100% Sequential Reads HGST Ultrastar 7K4000 SAS 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - 100% Sequential Reads
HGST Deskstar NAS 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Max Throughput - 50% Sequential Reads WD Red 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Max Throughput - 50% Sequential Reads WD Red Pro 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Max Throughput - 50% Sequential Reads Toshiba MG03ACA400 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Max Throughput - 50% Sequential Reads WD Se 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Max Throughput - 50% Sequential Reads Seagate Enterprise Capacity v4 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Max Throughput - 50% Sequential Reads Seagate NAS HDD 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Max Throughput - 50% Sequential Reads Seagate Terascale SED 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Max Throughput - 50% Sequential Reads WD Re 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Max Throughput - 50% Sequential Reads Seagate Constellation ES.3 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Max Throughput - 50% Sequential Reads HGST Ultrastar 7K4000 SAS 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Max Throughput - 50% Sequential Reads
HGST Deskstar NAS 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Random 8K - 70% Reads WD Red 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Random 8K - 70% Reads WD Red Pro 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Random 8K - 70% Reads Toshiba MG03ACA400 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Random 8K - 70% Reads WD Se 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Random 8K - 70% Reads Seagate Enterprise Capacity v4 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Random 8K - 70% Reads Seagate NAS HDD 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Random 8K - 70% Reads Seagate Terascale SED 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Random 8K - 70% Reads WD Re 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Random 8K - 70% Reads Seagate Constellation ES.3 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Random 8K - 70% Reads HGST Ultrastar 7K4000 SAS 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Random 8K - 70% Reads
HGST Deskstar NAS 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Real Life - 60% Random 65% Reads WD Red 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Real Life - 60% Random 65% Reads WD Red Pro 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Real Life - 60% Random 65% Reads Toshiba MG03ACA400 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Real Life - 60% Random 65% Reads WD Se 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Real Life - 60% Random 65% Reads Seagate Enterprise Capacity v4 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Real Life - 60% Random 65% Reads Seagate NAS HDD 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Real Life - 60% Random 65% Reads Seagate Terascale SED 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Real Life - 60% Random 65% Reads WD Re 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Real Life - 60% Random 65% Reads Seagate Constellation ES.3 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Real Life - 60% Random 65% Reads HGST Ultrastar 7K4000 SAS 4 TB - 3 HDDs / RAID-5 / 2x 1G - Real Life - 60% Random 65% Reads
We see that the sequential accesses are still limited by the network link, but, this time, on the NAS side. On the other hand, our random access tests show markedly better performance for the 7200 rpm drives. The HGST Deskstar NAS manages to almost reach the performance levels of the Seagate Enterprise Capacity v4 and the WD Red Pro at a much lower price point. There is only a slight premium over the WD Red and the Seagate NAS HDD, but the performance for simultaneous multi-client use-cases with non-sequential workloads is much better.