Archive 1997–2024

PCIe SSD Faceoff: Samsung XP941 (128GB & 256GB) and OCZ RevoDrive 350 (480GB) Tested

Random Read/Write Speed

The four corners of SSD performance are as follows: random read, random write, sequential read and sequential write speed. Random accesses are generally small in size, while sequential accesses tend to be larger and thus we have the four Iometer tests we use in all of our reviews.

Our first test writes 4KB in a completely random pattern over an 8GB space of the drive to simulate the sort of random access that you'd see on an OS drive (even this is more stressful than a normal desktop user would see). We perform three concurrent IOs and run the test for 3 minutes. The results reported are in average MB/s over the entire time.

Desktop Iometer - 4KB Random Read

Random read performance remains unchanged for the XP941 despite the lower capacity, while the RevoDrive does not really enjoy any performance increase over other SandForce based SSDs.

Desktop Iometer - 4KB Random Write

Desktop Iometer - 4KB Random Write (QD=32)

As for random write, the 256GB XP941 appears to be almost a match for the 512GB. The RevoDrive is a fairly interesting case because at low queue depths its performance is pretty bad, but the performance scales with the queue depth. Again, RAID only helps when there are multiple IOs in parallel, which only happens at high queue depths. At low queue depths RAID only seems to cause overhead, which would explain the low performance.

 

Sequential Read/Write Speed

To measure sequential performance we run a 1 minute long 128KB sequential test over the entire span of the drive at a queue depth of 1. The results reported are in average MB/s over the entire test length.

Desktop Iometer - 128KB Sequential Read

The XP941 continues to be strong, but the RevoDrive still does not offer much benefit over a SATA drive. We are dealing with a QD1 situation here so the RevoDrive cannot really take advantage of its internal parallelism.

Desktop Iometer - 128KB Sequential Write

AS-SSD Incompressible Sequential Read/Write Performance

The AS-SSD sequential benchmark uses incompressible data for all of its transfers. The result is a pretty big reduction in sequential write speed on SandForce based controllers, but most other controllers are unaffected.

Incompressible Sequential Read Performance

Incompressible Sequential Write Performance

 

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/8430/pcie-ssd-faceoff-samsung-xp941-128gb-256gb-and-ocz-revodrive-350-480gb-reviewed (Wayback Machine).