Archive 1997–2024

6 TB NAS Drives: WD Red, Seagate Enterprise Capacity and HGST Ultrastar He6 Face-Off

Single Client Access - DAS and NAS Environments

The drives under test were connected to a 6 Gbps SATA port off the PCH in our DAS testbed. After formatting in NTFS, they were subject to our DAS test suite. The results are presented in the table below.

6 TB NAS Drives Face-Off: DAS Benchmarks (MBps)
  WD Red 6 TB Seagate Enterprise Capacity v4 HGST Ultrastar He6
  Read Write Read Write Read Write
             
Photos 137.3 141.45 146.36 193.52 146.72 102.54
Videos 138.11 137.25 185.94 207.34 149.71 104.74
Blu-ray Folder 136.1 140.22 185.12 215.47 149.81 107.03
             
Adobe Photoshop (Light) 2.54 237.28 7.22 225.41 5.9 248.37
Adobe Photoshop (Heavy) 3.32 250.14 9.68 210.47 8.03 235.11
Adobe After Effects 2.27 96.75 7.27 49.66 5.98 17.05
Adobe Illustrator 2.36 101.77 7.11 163.16 5.9 71.59

On the NAS environment side, we configured three drives in RAID-5 in the QNAP TS-EC1279U-SAS-RP unit. Two of the network links were bonded (configured with 802.3ad LACP). Our usual Intel NASPT / robocopy benchmarks were processed from a virtual machine in our NAS testbed. The results are presented in the graph below.

CIFS Performance - Windows

The results above indicate that when it comes to a networked environment, the lower rotational speeds of the WD Red 6 TB are not much of an issue for single client accesses. It manages to acquit itself well in most of the test cases. Write-intensive workloads do cause the performance to drop a bit. Between the HGST Ultrastar He6 and the Seagate Enterprise Capacity, there is not much to help differentiate in this particular evaluation routine.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/8263/6-tb-nas-drives-wd-red-seagate-ec-hgst-he (Wayback Machine).