Archive 1997–2024

ASUS A88X-Pro Review: Kaveri, Kaveri, Quite Contrary

ASUS A88X-Pro Conclusion

High-end motherboards of any platform should come under strict scrutiny. The problem arises when one platform’s ‘high-end’ is the mainstream’s ‘lower-mid-range’. What is a premium on this cheaper platform is par for the course on the mainstream, which is an issue that can cloud judgment.

The ASUS A88X-Pro sits atop of the FM2+ stack with a variety of added features, especially over the $68 A88XM-E35 we reviewed previously. For almost double the cost, the ASUS A88X-Pro gives a larger overclock, more memory space, a better audio codec, more USB 3.0 ports, more SATA ports, support for Crossfire, intelligent processors to manage power consumption and a strong software platform. At the end of the day it performs slightly better at stock as well.

I have seen users in the comments of previous reviews on AnandTech comment along the following lines:

“If it costs 10% more but does not give +10% performance, what is the point?”

The A88X-Pro is never going to give +82% performance over the A88XM-E35. While the A88X-Pro offers +100% in DRAM slots and power delivery VRMs, it gives only +33% in USB 3.0 ports, +0% in network ports, an unknown percent in audio codec improvement and ~+30% in motherboard area. If we look at IO performance, asking for +82% seems silly. You cannot even put a percentage in terms of software and BIOS differences.

The flaw here is expecting linear gain for linear cost increase. To start there is a fixed base cost in the motherboard industry (chipset and PCB), then we must consider that moving up the stack in terms of feature set which increases both complexity and R&D cost. You are going to be up against the law of diminishing returns very early on. When deciding how much of a budget should be put towards a build, the motherboard segment often comes lower down the list (CPU, GPU and SSD might come first) unless you need specific functionality. But the market for high-end models still exists, and the A88X-Pro comes across as highly recommended in this range.

A side note: we are looking into the restarting flaw that seems to occur during our specialised benchmark under high CPU load. Signs may point towards early batch of Kaveri processors that draw higher current, or the silicon lottery. We need to get a newer one in to retest our Photoscan benchmark.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/7948/asus-a88x-pro-review (Wayback Machine).