ADATA XPG V2 Review: 2x8 GB at DDR3-2800 12-14-14 1.65 V
Conclusions
The problem these high MHz specification kits have is like a see-saw. If it had the real-world performance in line with price increments for memory, it would justify itself in the cost – but instead we get an inflated price for no real world benefit. This is endemic to any DRAM manufacturer who bids on these high end Hynix ICs just to provide themselves with promotion material to say ‘we sell high MHz DDR3’. Ultimately the only benchmarks that show any benefit are synthetic tests, and any real world test that benefits from high end memory tends to reach limiting returns around DDR3-2400 C10. Only specific memory limited compute tasks benefit from the high end numbers. Even in Dirt 3 minimum frame rates, where we usually see the biggest difference in memory timings, the results are obvious:

In this graph the x-axis is the Performance Index of the DRAM, and thus a PI of 200 can be 1600 C8 or 2400 C12.
Back in our pricing analysis, we saw a big jump moving from 2666 MHz to 2800 MHz memory:
$205: G.Skill TridentX 2x8 GB 2666 C12
$230: Team Xtreem 2x8 GB 2666 C11
$270: G.Skill TridentX 2x8GB 2666 C11
$320: Corsair Dominator Platinum 2x8GB 2666 C11
$320: Corsair Dominator Platinum 2x8GB 2666 C12
$600: G.Skill TridentX 2x8GB 2800 C12
$646: ADATA XPG V2 2x8GB 2800 C12
$730: Corsair Vengeance Pro 2x8GB 2800 C12
$750: G.Skill TridentX 2x8GB 2933 C12
At C11/C12, these memory kits perform roughly the same, meaning that the +100% price difference ($320 -> $646) is essentially another midrange GPU (or half a GTX 780 Ti) worth of cost. For that reason alone, no DDR3-2800+ kit is ever going to be justified in cost.
I cannot fault ADATA on their product – DDR3-2800 C12 is as DDR3-2800 C12 does. It overclocks a relatively small amount, and it pairs high specifications with high density and thus high price for little performance gain in our testing suite. My conclusion is essentially the same as with the G.Skill DDR3-3000 C12 2x4GB kit we tested (which was around the same price as this 2x8GB kit):
“It is a high price for a kit that offers little apart from a number parade. Perhaps the thing to remember is that plenty of memory manufacturers are also aiming at high MHz – Corsair, Avexir, TeamGroup, Apacer and others. If I had that money to spend on a daily Haswell system, I might plump for 4x8GB of DDR3-2400 C10 and upgrade the GPU with money left over.”
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/7583/adata-xpg-v2-review-2x8-gb-at-ddr32800-121414-165-v (Wayback Machine).
