Archive 1997–2024

Mushkin Atlas mSATA (240GB & 480GB) Review

Final Words

It's always good to see innovation from smaller OEMs instead of just the fab and controller IP owners. Mushkin, like most of the OEMs, are at the mercy of LSI/SandForce and fab owners when it comes to product availability. Crucial/Micron has been using 128Gbit NAND in their products for eight months now but none of the standalone SSD OEMs have gotten volume access to it yet, although this should change next year. However, this further reinforces the status and control of NAND fab owners -- when you get access to new technology a year or even longer before the others, you will always have an advantage. The best example is Samsung and their TLC NAND based 840 and 840 EVO because over a year later they are still the only OEM with a TLC SSD, giving them a substantial price advantage.

The Atlas is what you would expect from an mSATA SSD with SF-2281. It doesn't set any records but it's a decent performer. It's a bit unfortunate that the 480GB model is slower than the 240GB one, but I'm pretty confident that this is mostly due to the age and design of SF-2281, not Muskin's implementation.

NewEgg Price Comparison (12/16/2013)
  30GB 60/64GB 120/128GB 240/256GB 480GB
Mushkin Atlas $65 $135 $107 $195 $468
Crucial M500 - - $113 $176 -
Plextor M5M - $75 $112 $200 -
Intel SSD 525 - $80 $146 $290 -
ADATA XPG SX300 - $75 $110 $200 -

Atlas' pricing is fairly competitive but not earth-shattering. Given the NAND shortage issues, it's hard for fabless OEMs to continue the price war we had a couple of years ago. The days are behind when OEMs could buy a huge stock of NAND and get a significant discount -- now getting any stock at all can be an effort.

The 480GB Atlas was the only high capacity mSATA SSD when it was released earlier this year. However, now both Crucial and Samsung have retail mSATA SSDs in 480/500GB flavor as well (Samsung's upcoming 840 EVO mSATA even goes up to 1TB). Crucial's 480GB M500 mSATA isn't listed in the table since NewEgg doesn't have it but you can find it from Crucial's online store for $330. Given that the price difference is nearly $140, it's hard to recommend the Atlas 480GB at the moment. We haven't reviewed the M500 mSATA yet but we'll get to it in January once the CES rumble is over. Our SSD 840 EVO mSATA samples are currently on their way to our test lab and the review should be out before the holidays, so stay tuned for more mSATA related content!

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/7555/mushkin-atlas-msata-240gb-480gb-review (Wayback Machine).