Archive 1997–2024

2011 Media Streamer Roundup : Netgear NTV550, A.C.Ryan PlayOn!HD2 and the Boxee Box

Subtitles are an important part of the media experience. However, media streamers have been guilty of only including rudimentary support for SRT and SUB formats. With the rising popularity of Blu-ray backups and anime content, consumers have started looking for PGS support in various containers and also support for stylized subtitles (with karaoke effects, for example). In this section, we will explore the extent of subtitle support in the three media streamers.

Subtitle Compatibility Details
A.C.Ryan PlayOn!HD2
Firmware Version v9.5.3.r5440
Format Notes
PGS Supported only in M2TS (MKV Not Supported)
Forced Subtitles in MKV Not Supported
SRT External Subtitles Supported for All Formats
MKV Muxed Subtitles Supported
No Issues with Automatic Subtitle Encoding Detection (All Tested Languages Worked Fine)
SUB/IDX Supported with VOB in DVD Folder / ISO
MKV Muxed Subtitles / External Subtitles Not Supported
ASS / SSA Rudimentary Support (No Stylization)

 

Subtitle Compatibility Details
Netgear NTV550
Firmware Version 3.2.16NA
Format Notes
PGS Supported in both M2TS and MKV
Forced Subtitles in MKV Supported
SRT External Subtitles Supported for All Formats
MKV Muxed Subtitles Supported
Automatic Subtitle Encoding Detection Fails / Some Languages Don't Work (Vietnames, Thai, Korean, Arabic, Hebrew, Hindi and Japanese Don't Display Properly)
SUB/IDX External Subtitles Supported for All Formats
MKV Muxed Subtitles Supported
ASS / SSA Supported with Stylization (Stylization Effects Could be Smoother)

 

Subtitle Compatibility Details
D-Link Boxee Box
Firmware Version v1.2.2.20482
Format Notes
PGS Supported in both M2TS and MKV
Forced Subtitles in MKV Supported
SRT External Subtitles Supported for All Formats
MKV Muxed Subtitles Supported
No Issues with Automatic Subtitle Encoding Detection (All Tested Languages Worked Fine)
SUB/IDX External Subtitles Supported for All Formats
MKV Muxed Subtitles Supported
ASS / SSA Full Support with PC-Like Stylization

 

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/5129/2011-media-streamer-roundup-netgear-ntv550-acryan-playonhd2-and-the-boxee-box (Wayback Machine).