Archive 1997–2024

In Win Commander II 1200W

Voltage Regulation

+3.3V Regulation
Load Voltage
10% +2.42%
20% +2.12%
50% +0.61%
80% -0.91%
100% -1.82%
110% -1.12%

 

+5V Regulation
Load Voltage
10% +1.60%
20% +1.20%
50% +-0.00%
80% -1.00%
100% -1.40%
110% -2.00%

 

+12V Regulation (Worst Rail)
Load Voltage
10% +1.17%
20% +0.92%
50% +0.08%
80% -0.75%
100% -1.17%
110% -1.83%

The measurements are better than expected. +3.3V starts with a clear overvoltage, but the drop at higher loads is very low. +5V is within ATX specification too. The worst +12V rail performs very well with results very close to the optimal values. Despite the questionable information on the label, it is nice to see that this PSU has no problem with 1200W or even more. The label with 1079W combined power for +3.3V, +5V and +12V was very confusing but now we know 1200W is a reasonable rating for this PSU. Note that we did use a separate 16A power cord for testing.

Ripple and Noise

+3.3V Ripple Quality
Load Ripple and Noise
10% 8mV
20% 10mV
50% 15mV
80% 22mV
100% 22mV
110% 25mV

 

+5V Ripple Quality
Load Ripple and Noise
10% 9mV
20% 13mV
50% 18mV
80% 24mV
100% 25mV
110% 28mV

 

+12V Ripple Quality (Worst Rail)
Load Ripple and Noise
10% 26mV
20% 38mV
50% 53mV
80% 73mV
100% 89mV
110% 94mV

A big problem for this PSU are the relatively high ripple and noise results. ATX spec is that ripple should be within 1% on 12V and 5V, and up to 50mV on +3.3V, so 25-28mV is acceptable for the smaller rails. However, "acceptable" isn't the same as "good", and these are not the best results we have seen. Similarly, +12V is very close to 100mV, which is very close to the 120mV limit. That might be within the ATX requirements but we should keep in mind that the Commander II is a high-end PSU for gamers; the other +12V rails show similar values.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/4425/in-win-commander-ii-1200w (Wayback Machine).