Dell Precision T1600: Workstation Class
Conclusion: A Reliable Workhorse
First, let's dispense with the elephant in the room: yes, it's much cheaper to build your own workstation. If you were using consumer grade parts off the shelf, you could easily chop half the price tag off of our review system. Most of the enthusiasts here could build a substantially faster machine for less money, and the components in that machine would be warrantied for at least as long as the Dell Precision T1600.
Unfortunately, that's a problematic perspective. Even taking consumer/business product segmentation out of the equation, most businesses big or small don't have the benefit of someone like me or someone like you. I'm essentially in business for myself as a filmmaker and videographer, but I know how to tune an overclock and maintain my tower. If a part fails, I know how to replace it. I can build, tweak, and tune until the cows come home. Businesses typically don't have that luxury--or a desire to get into that sort of technical support.
In those instances, they're going to want a machine that's ISV certified for the applications they need to run; they may very well even need to create a small farm of machines like this. When I was in school we had a lab full of enterprise-class machines just like this T1600 designed for compositing/video editing and Adobe After Effects work. (And just to ruffle a few feathers, it's mostly independent houses that standardize on Macs and Final Cut Pro; smaller users like me are agile enough to use whatever's available and major production companies have been using Avid on PCs since time immemorial.) A business is going to need a machine they can rely on and service to back it up, and Dell is willing to provide both of these.
That being said, it's hard not to feel at least a little fleeced by Dell's upgrade pricing. The T1600 starts at 2GB of non-ECC DDR3, and the upgrade to 4GB is a ridiculous $135, nearly three times what that memory sells for at retail. Go up to ECC memory and suddenly the price explodes, with 8GB costing a downright obscene $780. This tower supports up to 16GB of non-ECC or 32GB of ECC DDR3. Crucial will sell you the same 8GB of ECC DDR3 at a lower price than Dell wants for 4GB of non-ECC kit. That's ignoring the $100 markup on the NVIDIA Quadro 2000 graphics card or the $200 markup on the processor. Workstations don't come cheap, but some of this is downright Apple pricing.
What you're really paying for are the certifications and the support. The T1600 is an entirely serviceable piece of hardware, comes with Office 2010 Starter standard, runs quietly and mostly efficiently (though 65% efficiency on the default power supply certainly isn't a selling point), and it will do the jobs it was intended for. Until HP refreshes their workstations with Sandy Bridge based Xeons, the Precision T1600 stands to be the only game in town and it's a fine one. Just be ready to pay for it.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/4299/dell-precision-t1600-workstation-class (Wayback Machine).