Archive 1997–2024

Western Digital Caviar Green 3TB and My Book Essential 3TB Drives Reviewed

Final Words

At $239 for an internal drive, the 3TB offering isn't too expensive. You can shave off another penny or two per GB if you go with a smaller drive, but if you want the space of a single drive Western Digital's offering isn't a bad deal. You have to go into this purchase with the right expectations however.

The performance difference between the 3TB Caviar Green and a modern 7200RPM drive can be significant depending on your workload. We saw WD's 3TB drive perform a lot like a notebook hard drive depending on the workload. If all you're using it for is to store large files, photos, videos, etc... then you'll be fine. But I wouldn't recommend using it as a boot/application drive, the random performance and even light workload performance just doesn't measure up.

The 3TB drive (or a pair of them in RAID 1) would be a great companion to an SSD for all of your mass storage needs. As SSDs grow in size and popularity, I'm not sure we'll need to have 7200RPM hard drives in desktops any longer. These sub-6K RPM drives may be enough to get the job done. Sequential read/write speed is within 10% of Seagate's 2TB 7200RPM Barracuda XT, and I suspect that's all you need if you have a very fast SSD for your OS and applications.

As far as the external drive goes. Kudos to Western Digital for a well executed chassis, however I am concerned about the somewhat erratic read/write performance I noted in my testing of the drive.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/3981/western-digital-caviar-green-3tb-and-my-book-essential-3tb-drives-reviewed (Wayback Machine).