Gateway ID49: Mixing the Bag
Lookin' for Bling in All the Wrong Places
To say the Gateway ID49C is a mixed bag would be a gross understatement: the notebook feels downright schizophrenic. On the one hand, Gateway has clearly tried to produce a classier, more upscale model, and in some ways they've succeeded. Aluminum styling is always attractive, and opting to use as little glossy plastic as humanly possible is welcome in a world where major companies like Toshiba and Dell still aren't fully grasping that "less is more." Which is to say: less glossy plastic is more attractive. The ID49C is very svelte, reasonably light, and offers fine performance in a portable form factor.
The problem is that when you see the investments made into using aluminum, getting the unit slim, and for the love of whatever deity you believe in, backlighting the touchpad, you can't help but feel like the whole design is wrong-headed. Gateway's answering questions no one was asking while leaving the usual problems utterly unchecked.
I'd trade the aluminum for matte plastic if it meant a better screen, replacing the keyboard with something useful, or at least adding a USB 3.0 port. But no, instead of a halfway decent screen or even a combo eSATA/USB port, we get a backlit touchpad. Backlighting the touchpad and getting rid of dedicated document navigation controls was more important.
It's hard to be positive about the ID49C when the trade-offs are so bad, because you sit there and you see where investments were made and where they should've been made, and you watch Gateway utterly whiff with the ID49C. The notebook has a lot of wasted potential; having decent performance under the hood is nice, but the keyboard and the screen are how you interact with a computer, and if those are bad enough to make you not want to use the machine, who cares how fast it is?
Viewed within a vacuum, the ID49C's $849 pricetag is justifiable and I could see someone walking away with one. It's slim, fairly attractive, and the specs are respectable. Battery life may not be exciting, but it's still very reasonable. The performance is a bit less than the ASUS N82Jv we looked at last week, but $150 less is something to take note of. Unfortunately, while the N82Jv wasn't a clear win, at least the keyboard and touchpad were decent. Unless you happen to be one of those who like this awful keyboard design—do such people exist? Enquiring minds want to know!—that coupled with the dismal screen and lack of expandability make this a much harder sell, and you're left staring at a backlit touchpad and wondering about what could've been.
Given NVIDIA recently announced their new 400M parts, Gateway should take the ID49C back to the drawing board and make a few judicious changes. Kill the glowing touchpad, give us a backlit keyboard (with no flex or flowing island keys please), and try to find a better LCD. And while you're at it, make one of the USB ports 3.0 compatible. For that, we'd happily pay $1000, but the current pricing ultimately reflects on the fact that Gateway cut the wrong corners.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/3940/gateway-id49-mixing-the-bag (Wayback Machine).