Archive 1997–2024

Server Clash: DELL's Quad Opteron DELL R815 vs HP's DL380 G7 and SGI's Altix UV10

In Summary

Below we have a quick summary of the pros and cons for each of the three servers we talked about today. As always, the full story can't be distilled down to a few lines but if you're looking for a recap hopefully this helps.

SGI Altix UV 10/ QSSC-4R

Pro:

  • Extreme expandability : 64 DIMMs, 10 PCIe slots
  • Cold Redundancy and 2 + 2 PSU
  • RAS features
  • Low response times in all kinds of circumstances (X7560)

 

Con:

  • High power consumption in general; low utilization power consumption too high
  • Only the X7560 delivers really high end performance

 

Dell PowerEdge R815

Pro:

  • 2U rack space saving form factor and...
  • Performance and expandability of a 4U
  • Best price/performance ratio of the market
  • Competitive performance/watt

Con:

  • Higher response times for the individual VMs in some real world situations (20-40% load)

 

HP Proliant DL380 G7

Pro:

  • Low response times in most "non-peak" situations
  • Cold redundancy
  • Competitive performance/watt
  • Very low energy use when underutilized

Con:

  • Relatively high price/performance ratio compared to Dell R815
  • Too many "options" (risers, unnecessary DIMMs, drive bays)

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/3894/server-clash-dellr815 (Wayback Machine).