Archive 1997–2024

Powerline Networking with the Western Digital Livewire

The WD Livewire was benchmarked, and found to offer no improvements performance wise when compared with the plethora of already existing powerline adapters with similar specifications. It is hard to justify pricing the kit at $139.99, but, thankfully it can already be found online for much lesser (at the time of writing this review). The only advantage it offers over existing adapters is the fact that it has 4 ports on either side. This enables it to act as a port multiplier at the router end, allowing consumers to avoid investing in a switch to connect to the router for this purpose. The WD brand name can also be trusted to include quality internal components for longer product life, when compared to some of the other low cost powerline adapters in the market.

Had the WD Livewire been released a year back, we would have given it our unreserved recommendation. Unfortunately, not only is the kit late to the market for its specifications, the consumer demands have also increased in the meanwhile. The 'Stream HD' claim on the box is also quite hollow, as we could not stream Blu-Ray content to the WDTV Live in a reliable manner. Granted, 720p worked fine, and could also be termed HD, but consumers need to be aware that in most situations 1080p is a no-go, particularly at Blu-Ray bitrates. That said, we did find it to be more stable than Wireless-N streaming at our test locations.

Four ports on either side also looks to be an overkill for the consumer market. It looks inviting for a SOHO (Small Office / Home Office) environment, but the transfer speeds remain a dampener. This should hopefully improve in the next generation products.

In summary, we can say that the WD Livewire is a good investment if the consumer is looking to purchase a switch to get more Ethernet ports near the router, and also urgently needs to set up a powerline network at home. We are not quite sure how big such a market would be. Western Digital will most probably not encounter the same sort of success with the WD Livewire as it did with the WDTV. However, the product experience should stand in good stead for the company to develop and introduce the next generation products in the Livewire family. We are looking forward to higher speeds over electrical wires and tighter integration with the ShareSpace and WDTV product lines. WD would have a winner on their hands in such a scenario.
 

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/3860/powerline-networking-with-the-western-digital-livewire (Wayback Machine).