Archive 1997–2024

The HTC Droid Incredible Review, Clearly Better than the Nexus One

Perplexing Performance

To measure web browsing performance I downloaded a bunch of different web pages and saved as much of them as possible locally on a server. I used WiFi (802.11g) on all of the devices to connect to my local server and timed average load time. I repeated the test at least 3 times and threw out any unusually high or low numbers. Performance on the Android devices was from a clean restart with no unnecessary programs running in memory.

What these tests should show is the overall performance of the platform when all network bottlenecks are removed. Obviously hiding in a tunnel under a lead umbrella will make any phone slow, but we’re looking at peak performance here.

The first test is the new AnandTech front page. Here we’ve got tons of images and HTML, meaning we’re stressing both bandwidth and code parsing speed.

As I already mentioned, the HTC Droid Incredible is actually a bit slower than the Nexus One. The iPhone v. Nexus One gap isn’t that big but the Incredible is slower than both.

Next up we have the first page of our recent Zotac XBOX HD-ID11 review. The balance shifts from tons of images to more HTML processing, here we should see a big advantage from the 1GHz Snapdragon:

HTC’s web browser squanders most of the performance advantage awarded by the Snapdragon SoC, the Nexus One is noticeably faster here.

Using our Print this Review function, this next test loads our entire 2010 15-inch Macbook Pro review. While the other two tests had some flash ad content, this one is completely devoid of it so the Incredible shouldn’t be penalized:

Unfortunately it doesn’t seem to matter, whatever HTC has done to the Android browser has made it slower even if you don’t have any Flash on the page. The iPhone advantage here is partly due to Apple’s aggressive caching of web pages. No other smartphone platform appears to cache unchanged content as well as Apple. It’s not all due to that however, even the first run on the 3GS was faster than either of the Android phones. As we can see just by looking at the Incredible vs. the Nexus One, software optimizations can have a significant impact on performance.

Our most intensive test is up next with a load of the Engadget front page:

The Incredible falls flat on its face here. The iPhone 3GS and Nexus One are much faster.

Our most CPU bound test is up next. I put together a custom page with a ton of tabular content and a single page copy of our 15-inch MBP review to make the load take some time at least.

The Snapdragon advantage is very evident, but again we see that the HTC Incredible is still slower than the Nexus One.

Our final test shows the 3GS ahead, a rare but plausible scenario depending on the nature of the page.

On average the Nexus One was 11% faster than the iPhone 3GS, and 34% faster than the HTC Incredible. I will say that the Incredible never felt slow but that’s partly due to the fact that its animations were always so fast/smooth.

Javascript performance shows that the Incredible has the potential to be fast. It actually outpaced the Nexus One here:

I’m hoping that whatever is at fault here can be addressed with a software update.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/3710/the-htc-droid-incredible-review-clearly-better-than-the-nexus-one (Wayback Machine).