Archive 1997–2024

Gateway and Acer Netbooks: Wonder Twin Powers, Activate!

Acer and Gateway Netbooks: Typical Pine Trail

One of the biggest challenges in reviewing netbooks is differentiating between them and deciding what really separates the best in class from the also-rans. Unfortunately, with all of the performance and feature parity shared by the standard bearers, this is a really difficult task. With established hardware manufacturers like Dell, HP, Acer, ASUS, and MSI making cohesive and well-thought-out devices, the quality of design and manufacturing ends up similar, so often personal preference separates the various netbooks on paper. In practice, the only thing that differs is the quality of the screen, which is dependant on how much priority the manufacturer places on the LCD. Beyond that, there isn’t a whole lot to separate any netbook from the rest of the class.

At the end of the day, the Aspire One 532h and LT2120u are just netbooks. Solid competitors in the netbook class, but nothing mind blowing, and not really good enough to knock the ASUS Eee 1001P off its throne. They're not built quite as well and the LCD isn't near the high quality panel the ASUS uses, but the Aspire One (and Gateway clone) are still capable netbooks. I can't recommend them over the 1001P, primarily because of the LCD, but other than that the difference between them and the rest of the netbook class is pretty slight. The Acer and Gateway are both specced and priced to equal the 1001P and others, so if you prefer the Acer or Gateway brands, these are definitely up to scratch.

And of course, we would be remiss if we didn't mention where CULV machines fall in all of this. You can get a single-core CULV machine like the Acer 1410 for within $70 of the cost of these netbooks. This is true for any of the netbooks in the running—not just the Gateway and Acer, but also the Eee 1001P and everything else. Spending another $50-100 could get you a dual-core processor, but then you are paying significantly more than a netbook. If you are willing to spend a little more, you can get vastly improved performance and features, but with less battery life and a higher cost.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/3679/gateway-and-acer-netbooks (Wayback Machine).