Archive 1997–2024

AMD's 12-core "Magny-Cours" Opteron 6174 vs. Intel's 6-core Xeon

The SKUs

 

The Opteron 6176 looks a bit ridiculous as it delivers only 4% more performance at 30% higher power and 20% higher prices. The real reason behind this CPU is to battle another tanker, the Nehalem EX that Intel is going to launch tomorrow.  The TDP and clockspeeds of that huge chip are very similar. If your application scales poorly and you don't care about power consumption, the X5677 is your champion; it is probably the fastest chip on the market for applications with low thread counts.  

AMD vs. Intel 2-socket SKU Comparison
Intel Xeon Model
Cores TDP Speed (GHz) Price AMD Opteron Model Cores TDP GHz Price
W5680 6 130W 3.30 GHz $1663 6176 SE 12 105/137W 2.3 GHz $1386
X5670 6 95W 2.93 GHz $1440          
X5660 6 95W 2.80 GHz $1219 6174 12 80/115W 2.2 GHz $1165
X5650 6 95W 2.66 GHz $996 6172 12 80/115W 2.1 GHz $989
                   
X5677 4 130W 3.46 GHz $1663 2439SE 6 105/137W 2.8 GHz ?
X5667 4 95W 3.06 GHz $1440          
          6168 12 80/115W 1.9 GHz $744
E5640 4 80W 2.66 GHz $744 6136 8 80/115W 2.4 GHz $744
E5630 4 80W 2.53 GHz $551 6134 8 80/115W 2.3 GHz $523
E5620 4 80W 2.40 GHz $387 6128 8 80/115W 2.0 GHz $266
                   
L5640 6 60W 2.26 GHz $996 6164 HE 12 65/? W 1.7 GHz $744
          6128 HE 8 65/? W 2.0 GHz $523
          6124 HE 8 65/? W 1.8 GHz $455
L5630 4 40W 2.13 GHz $551          
L5620 4 40W 1.86 GHz $440          

 

The most interesting parts that AMD offers are the dodeca-core 6174 (2.2GHz), the octal-core 6136 (2.4GHz) and the octal-core low power 6128 (2.0GHz).  The 6174 targets those with well scaling multi-threaded applications such as huge databases and virtualized loads. The 8-core 6136 might even be better as most schedulers find it easier to distribute threads and process over a power of 2 cores. Lots of applications also don't scale beyond 16 cores and the chip comes with a 200MHz clockspeed bonus and a very reasonable price.

The 6128 HE is also an interesting one. The 6128 HE might be a good way to reconcile low response times with low power, but we'll have to find that out later.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2978/amd-s-12-core-magny-cours-opteron-6174-vs-intel-s-6-core-xeon (Wayback Machine).