Archive 1997–2024

AMD Athlon 2650e & X2 3250e - Better than Atom for SFF Desktops

Power Consumption: Higher than Atom

I don’t have a zino HD here to test, but I can hook up a 780G board and Atom 330/ION board to the same PSU and to get an idea for power consumption. The directly comparable numbers are those bars in orange and green. They use the same ATX power supply, the rest use external DC bricks.

Idle Power Consumption

As you’d expect, the AMD system does eat more power. At idle the Athlons actually use around the same amount of power as the Atom 330 system (presumably Pine Trail would use less but I don’t have a good apples-to-apples comparison using the same PSU). Under load, AMD is more power hungry.

Load Power Consumption (x264 HD 1st Pass)

The dual-core Athlon X2 3250e actually shot up the most at almost 65W compared to 44.2W for the Atom setup.

From a power efficiency standpoint you’re obviously better off with Atom. It makes sense. Intel argued that you can only scale a desktop processor down so much before it’s more efficient to start with a brand new design to address a different power envelope.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2900 (Wayback Machine).