Archive 1997–2024

AMD's Six-Core Opteron 2435

What Intel and AMD are Offering

Before we can dive into benchmarks, it is good to see how the vendors position their CPUs. Before we do that, a quick specsheet of the most important AMD and Intel CPUs.

Model Speed (GHz) Max. clock 4 cores busy (GHz) L2 Cache (KB) L3 Cache (MB) Interconnect Bandwidth in One Direction
Intel Xeon X5570 2.93 3.2 4 x 256 KB 8 MB 12.3 GB/s
Intel Xeon X5560 2.80 3.066 4 x 256 KB 8 MB 12.3 GB/s
Intel Xeon X5550 2.66 2.93 4 x 256 KB 8 MB 12.3 GB/s
AMD Opteron 2435 2.6 2.6 6 x 512 KB 6 MB 9.8 GB/s
Intel Xeon E5540 2.53 2.66 4 x 256 KB 8 MB 11.7 GB/s
AMD Opteron 2431 2.4 2.4 6 x 512 KB 6 MB 8.8 GB/s
AMD Opteron 2389 2.9 2.9 4 x 512 KB 6 MB 8.8 GB/s
Intel Xeon E5530 2.4 2.53 4 x 256 KB 8 MB 11.7 GB/s
Intel Xeon E5430 2.66 2.66 2 x 6 MB N/A Via FSB
AMD Opteron 2427 2.2 2.2 6 x 512 KB 6 MB 8.8 GB/s
AMD Opteron 2384 2.6 2.6 6 x 512 KB 6 MB 4 GB/s
Intel Xeon E5520 2.26 2.33 4 x 256 KB 8 MB 11.7 GB/s
Intel Xeon E5506 2.13 2.13 4 x 256 KB 4MB 9.8 GB/s
AMD Opteron 2378 2.4 2.4 4 x 512 KB 6 MB 4 GB/s

What do you get for your money? The six-cores of AMD are shown in “forest green”.

Intel Xeon Model Speed (GHz) / TDP Price AMD Opteron Model Speed (GHz) / TDP - ACP Price
X5570 2.93 / 95W $1386      
X5560 2.80 x 95W $1172      
X5550 2.66 / 95W $958 2435 2.6 / 75-115W $989
E5540 2.53 / 80W $744 2431 2.4 / 75-115W $698
      2389 2.9 / 75-115W $698
E5530 2.4 / 80W $530 2387 2.8 / 75-115W $523
L5520 2.26 / 60W $530 2376 HE 2.3 / 55-79W $575
L5510 2.13 / 60W $423 2374 HE 2.2 / 55-79W $450
E5520 2.26 $373 2427 2.2 / 75-115W $455
E5506 2.13 $266 2382 2.6 / 75-115W $316
E5504 2.00 $224      
E5502 1.86 $188 2378 2.4 / 75-115W $174

AMD has clearly recognized that it can not beat the best Xeon X55xx when it comes to raw performance. The two top models, the X5570 and X5560 stay out of reach. AMD is basically saying that – with the right application – the new six-core Opteron should be able to keep up with equally clocked Xeons X55xx. In case of the 2435, you get lower power consumption as a bonus. Notice also that the best quad-core Opterons have become significantly cheaper. The 2.9 GHz 2389 “Shanghai”, which used to be positioned against the 2.66 GHz X5550 is now competing with the E5540. The 2.9 GHz Shanghai is still no match for the Xeon E5540 2.53 but it is important to look at the complete server price. 32 GB of reg DDR-3 1066 still costs about $1200, whereas 32 GB of DDR-2 800 costs around $850. It is out of the scope of this article, but it is clear that even if the CPUs cost the same, the AMD based server will be less costly. The Xeon X55xx is after all a very new platform.

For those who love stats, the die size and transistor count table:

CPU Transitor Count (Million) Process Die Size Cores
Intel Dunnington (Xeon 74xx) 1900 45 nm 504 mm2 6
Intel Gainestown (Xeon 55xx) 731 45 nm 265 mm2 4
AMD Istanbul (Opteron 24xx) 904 45 nm 346 mm2 6
AMD Shanghai (Opteron >237x) 705 45 nm 263 mm2 4
AMD Barcelona (Opteron 23xx) 463 65 nm 283 mm2 4
Intel Tigerton (Xeon 73xx) 2 x 291 = 582 65 nm 2 x 143 mm2 4
Intel Harpertown (Xeon 54xx) 2 x 410 = 820 45 nm 2 x 107 mm2 4

AMD’s Istanbul is quite a large chip, but not as expensive as “Barcelona” to produce. The champion is the Harpertown when it comes to the lowest production costs.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2774 (Wayback Machine).