Archive 1997–2024

ASUS W90Vp: ATI Mobility Radeon HD 4870... with CrossFire

Test Setup

We've removed many of the previously tested notebooks, in particular many of the lower end notebooks that aren't designed to compete with a high-end gaming system. We did keep a few midrange systems and some of the charts as a reference point, but even then we have to caution that driver updates may have changed performance. You want to focus more on the Clevo D901C results if you're interested in seeing a comparable notebook.

ASUS W90Vp-A1 Test System
Processor Core 2 Quad Q9000 (2.00GHz 1066FSB 2x3MB L2)
Overclocking to 2.29GHz (1221FSB)
Memory 3x2048MB Transcend PC2-6400 @ DDR2-667 5-5-5-15
(Hyundai Electronics HYMP125S64CP8-S6)
Graphics 2 x ATI Mobility Radeon 4870 (CrossFire) 512MB
GPU/RAM Clocks: 550/1700 MHz (256-bit), 350/400 MHz Low Power
Driver version 8.055.1.2
Beta ATI Drivers 8.612
Display 18.4" Glossy Full HD 1080p (1920x1080)
Samsung 184HT01-A01
Hard Drive 2 x Seagate Momentus 7200.3 320GB 7200RPM 16MB (ST9320421AS)
Optical Drive 8x SATA DVDR/BDROM (Optiarc BC-5500S)
Battery 12-Cell 97.7Whr
Operating System Windows Vista Home Premium SP1 64-bit
Price Starting at ~$2500 online

As mentioned earlier, we received a beta driver from ATI that affected the results in numerous titles. We will include results from both drivers so that you can see what you're missing if you have to wait for new drivers. Even if ASUS/ATI updates the drivers on their website to offer this beta driver, that's only a short-term solution. What happens in six months when there are many more new titles launching? We shall see shortly that CrossFire support is still MIA in a few titles, and that will be the case with every new release between now and the next driver update.

Since we only have one competitive gaming laptop available for testing right now, we also wanted to look at how performance compares to a desktop 4870X2. There are a few noteworthy differences between the desktop and notebook systems, starting with the CPU. This is my own personal gaming machine, with an overclocked 3.30GHz Q6600 (yup, it's still chugging along nicely). The desktop HD 4870X2 runs at higher clock speeds than the Mobility Radeon HD 4870, and it comes with 2GB of RAM (1GB per GPU). Furthermore, the desktop parts utilize GDDR5, which is quad-pumped so the 900MHz memory results in an effective clock speed of 3600MHz. Here's a quick rundown of the desktop system specifications.

Desktop Test System
Processor Core 2 Quad Q6600 Overclocked (3.30GHz 1468FSB 2x4MB L2)
Memory 2x2048MB OCZ PC2-6400 @ DDR2-734 4-4-4-12
Graphics ATI Radeon 4870X2 2GB
GPU/RAM Clocks: 750/3600 MHz (256-bit)
9.5 Catalyst Drivers
Hard Drive Samsung F1 750GB 7200RPM 32MB
Operating System Windows Vista Ultimate SP1 64-bit

Having a faster CPU means that there's less potential for a CPU bottleneck, so CPU limited benchmarks will be up to 43% faster than the overclocked W90Vp. Some benchmarks will also be limited by GPU memory bandwidth, where the HD 4870X2 is potentially 112% faster than the Mobility 4870 -- please note that very few titles are actually memory bandwidth constrained. Finally, the clock speed of the desktop card is 36% higher than the mobile part. In short, whether we are CPU or GPU limited, we expect the desktop system to be up to 40% faster than the W90Vp, unless there's some other problem (i.e. drivers). In order to help remove the CPU bottleneck as much as possible, we will focus on performance at 1080p and maximum quality settings for comparing the two systems.

Notebook configurations for the other laptops are at the following pages:

Acer 6920G
Alienware m15x
ASUS G50V
ASUS U6V
AVADirect FL-92
Clevo D901C (Note: upgraded to 2x2GB DDR2-667)
Dell Studio XPS 16
Gateway P-7808u FX
Gateway P-7811 FX
HP dv5t
MSI GT627
Toshiba X305-Q725

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2772 (Wayback Machine).