Archive 1997–2024

The Core 2 Quad Q8400: Intel's $183 Phenom II 940 Competitor

Phenom II Earns a Financially Troubled AMD Less per Chip than Core 2 Quad

The global economy isn’t exactly strong right now. People are still buying, just not nearly as much as before when it felt like money grew on trees. Financially, all companies have been hurt, but AMD has much bigger issues. The table below shows net income in millions of US dollars before taxes for AMD and Intel over the past four quarters:

Net Income Before Taxes Q1 2009 Q4 2008 Q3 2008 Q2 2008
AMD -$298 Million -$1,358 Million $22 Million -$682 Million
Intel $629 Million $369 Million $2,833 Million $2,313 Million

 

Yeah. Ouch. Granted Intel going from ~$2.8B of income in a quarter down to under $400M must’ve hurt, but AMD has lost over $2.3B in the past four quarters. The company isn’t profitable and unfortunately is stuck between a rock and a hard place when it comes to fixing that.

The financial issues extend beyond simple CPU sales but I must point out the obvious issue with AMD’s current strategy. We know that the Phenom II is competitive, but look at what it’s competing against:

Processor L1 Cache L2 Cache L3 Cache Total Cache (4-core) Transistor Count Die Size
AMD Phenom II 128K per core 512KB per core 6MB 8.5MB 758M 258mm2
Intel Core 2 Quad Q9x50 64KB per core 12MB N/A 12.25MB 820M 214mm2
Intel Core 2 Quad Q9x00 64KB per core 6MB N/A 6.25MB 456M 164mm2
Intel Core 2 Quad Q8xxx 64KB per core 4MB N/A 4.25MB 456M 164mm2

 

Every single Phenom II uses a single 258 mm2 45nm die, that’s nearly Nehalem-sized. The problem is that the Phenom II parts generally compete against Intel’s Core 2 Quad Q9x00 and Q8xxx series, both of which have a total die size of 164mm2. AMD’s Phenom II die is 57% larger.

AMD and Intel both manufacture on 300mm wafers, but Intel can get nearly 60% more CPUs for each wafer than AMD can thanks to its die size advantage. That translates into more revenue per wafer and a significant profit advantage for Intel.

AMD’s Phenom II is very competitive, but the strategy does not have much long term staying power. AMD needs to introduce smaller die versions of its CPUs soon.

The deeper ramifications of AMD’s current situation are troubling. I’m not sure what impact all of this is having on the development of AMD’s next-generation architectures, but I suspect that it can’t be good.

The Test

Motherboard: Intel DX48BT2 (Intel X48)
MSI DKA790GX Platinum (AMD 790GX)
Chipset: Intel X48
AMD 790GX
Chipset Drivers: Intel 9.1.1.1010 (Intel)
AMD Catalyst 8.12
Hard Disk: Intel X25-M SSD (80GB)
Memory: G.Skill DDR2-800 2 x 2GB (4-4-4-12)
G.Skill DDR2-1066 2 x 2GB (5-5-5-15)
Qimonda DDR3-1066 4 x 1GB (7-7-7-20)
Video Card: eVGA GeForce GTX 280
Video Drivers: NVIDIA ForceWare 180.43 (Vista64)
NVIDIA ForceWare 178.24 (Vista32)
Desktop Resolution: 1920 x 1200
OS: Windows Vista Ultimate 32-bit (for SYSMark)
Windows Vista Ultimate 64-bit

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2762 (Wayback Machine).