AMD Shanghai Launch - Database Testing
- Posted in
- IT Computing
Idle Power and AS3AP Performance

We tested the systems, at idle, with both four DIMM and eight DIMM configurations. The impact was not as significant on the AMD system as it was on the Intel system. The difference in power consumption on the AMD system is only 7W but on the Intel system it was 49W.
Barcelona uses 6% more power at idle than Shanghai. The eight DIMM Intel system uses 56% more power than Shanghai, and the four DIMM Intel system uses 30% more power than Shanghai. A large chunk of this difference on Intel clearly comes from the FB-DIMMs, given the power scaling from four to eight FB-DIMMs, but AMD may still have a slight lead overall even if we discount the memory.

For the first three load points it is close but Intel is able to lead by an average of 15%. Once we hit load point four all systems are almost identical and then with load point five Shanghai is able to lead by as much as 11%. In the first four load points, the performance of Shanghai @ 2.7 GHz vs. Barcelona @ 2.3 GHz is within 2% even though there is a 17% bump in clock. At load point five, Shanghai is able to outpace Barcelona by 11% but still less than the clock bump.

Shanghai and Barcelona exhibit similar CPU usage profiles for the first few load points and then you see that Barcelona @ 2.3 GHz maxes out.

The Opterons are the clear leaders from a power perspective. Shanghai uses approximately 12% less power than Barcelona. Intel uses 27% to 46% more power than Shanghai, depending on the DIMM configuration.

At all load points, Shanghai is the clear winner. For the first four load points Shanghai is again ~12% more efficient than Barcelona, and as much as 28% or 47% more efficient than the Intel systems depending upon the DIMM configuration.
Note: The line for Harpertown four DIMMs is dotted in the above graphs because we did not actually run this configuration but speculate this is the power consumption based on idle power consumption analysis.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2666 (Wayback Machine).