Archive 1997–2024

The All-in-One Battle: Dell's XPS One 24 vs. Apple's iMac

Can You Game on It?

So here's an interesting comparison, let's look at the graphics hardware in both the Dell XPS One 24 and the top of the line 24" Apple iMac:

  Apple iMac - $2199 Dell XPS One 24 - $2299
GPU NVIDIA GeForce 8800 GS NVIDIA GeForce 9600M
SPs 64 32
Memory Bus 256-bit 128-bit

 

See a problem? The Mac actually has a far more powerful GPU, which in theory means...

Fallout 3 Performance - High Quality Settings, No AA 1024 x 640 1280 x 800 1920 x 1200
Apple iMac - $2199 - Vista 70.8 fps 65.5 fps 48.5 fps
Dell XPS One 24 - $2299 - Vista 25.6 fps 21.5 fps 14.1 fps

 

Yep, much higher gaming performance. Fallout 3, just released this month, plays wonderfully on the iMac at high quality settings but struggles on the XPS One 24. Now neither machine is intended to be used for gaming, but one of the two actually can be and it's got an image of a common fruit on the front bezel - a bit unexpected.

Just for kicks I tried Red Alert 3, a real time strategy game also just released with lower frame rate demands. Unfortunately we see the same sort of performance breakdown - while the iMac can work as a light duty gaming system, the GeForce 9600M is just not up to the task. The GeForce 8800 GS in the iMac has around 2x the shader power of what Dell put in the XPS One 24, the results speak for themselves.

Red Alert 3 Performance - High Quality Settings, No AA 1024 x 640 1920 x 1200
Apple iMac - $2199 - Vista 30 fps 30 fps
Dell XPS One 24 - $2299 - Vista 15 fps 7 fps

 

In an attempt to keep the thermals manageable in the XPS One 24, Dell opted for a mobile GPU from NVIDIA - the GeForce 9600M. Apple instead relied on the GeForce 8800 GS (the same GPU as the GeForce 9600 GSO), which we've shown recently as capable of running most modern titles at 1280 x 1024. Now neither GPU is powerful enough to drive a modern game at reasonable settings at the native panel resolution (1920 x 1200), but gaming at 1024 x 768 and 1280 x 1024 should be easily possible on the iMac.

The XPS One 24 can run less stressful games or modern games at lower resolutions/detail settings, but as strange as it is to say, the iMac is better for gaming.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2656 (Wayback Machine).