Archive 1997–2024

NVIDIA 9500 GT: Mainstream Graphics Update

Final Words

This is not an exciting launch. The 9500 GT doesn't offer much more performance than the 8600 GT it replaces. The price is okay at between $70 and $80, but the 8600 GT can be had for the same cost as well. While this is a different class of hardware than integrated graphics, these are still just cards for people who aren't invested in playing today's games.

We have gotten used to not expecting much from sub $100 parts. Graphics card companies need to make money, and we can't expect them to give away hardware will killer features and performance. But there are multiple issues with the current state of low end graphics.

Setting the bar too low makes it so that game developers have to put time and energy into targeting crappy hardware. Putting time into making the game work takes away from the time and energy they could available for making the game better. This is a much more difficult than developing for consoles, as their target is relatively high at launch and doesn't change for a good 4 or 5 years. With the current worries over piracy on the PC, we don't need any more difficulty thrown at developers. Giving consumers a reasonable baseline performance for less than $100 is essential to keep game developers interested in and writing for the PC.

Additionally, people who have cheap hardware don't know what they are missing with higher performance parts, but they have no way to experience something that looks good enough to show them why they should care. What we want to see are low end parts that can run all the latest and greatest features that the high end cards can run at reasonable frame rates at very low resolutions. I don't care if it's 640x480 at 30 frames per second, we need hardware that can push through very complex shaders and textures for the good of the PC gaming industry.

It is possible that Larrabee could be a disruptive technology in this market. If Intel is able to deliver a top to bottom launch on day one with volume on all parts, the way graphics hardware is addressed could see a fundamental shift. We might just see the competition realize that they need to change their ways and address the all important low end space with new generations as quickly as possible.

If NVIDIA and AMD can't adjust their strategy for the good of the industry, they might reassess things for the good of their bottom line once a true third competitor comes along in the graphics space. While we still don't know how Larrabee will perform, or even how Intel will approach real desktop graphics, we have a lot of hope that even if this x86 based graphics hardware falls on its face that the competition will not place its hope on Intel's failure.

NVIDIA and AMD need to have a healthy fear and respect for Intel, if only due to the size of their research, development, fabrication, and marketing budgets. The sheer volume of money Intel can pour into this project and not bat an eye is huge. We hope, for their sakes and ours, that NVIDIA and AMD realize this fact.

Who knows, maybe NVIDIA and AMD are already betting on Intel pushing forward with a top to bottom launch of competitive hardware. Maybe they are hard at work on a strategy to improve the quality of the low end hardware they offer and to bring out their parts for a given generation all at once.

And maybe next year we'll see Duke Nukem Forever.

It's nice to dream sometimes ...

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2612 (Wayback Machine).