NVIDIA 9500 GT: Mainstream Graphics Update
- Posted in
- GPUs
The Card
This card, being built on a smaller process than it's predecessor, is capable of more performance in the same form factor. Alternate, NVIDIA could make it a little cooler and little quieter and still hit the same or slightly better performance than the part they are replacing. This seems to be the option they have selected for the 9500 GT.
But there is a fundamental issue with the timing of NVIDIA's low end releases. We see high end parts first, mid-range parts next, and low end parts last for any given GPU generation. While we do enjoy the fact that AMD has decided to target the mid-range first and then expand up and down in performance later, their history shows a trend of taking too long to bump up the performance of their lowest common denominator. AMD is promising some change in this area very soon, but we will have to wait until we finish our tests and are able to talk about that to ... well ... talk about that :-)
There are reasons that this makes business sense. For example, parts from higher price brackets, once replaced by faster hardware can be sold at lower price points before new hardware is available. This wouldn't be as effective with a top to bottom launch of new hardware (or if either company started with the low end). But that doesn't change the fact that the less the low end lags current technology, the faster new techniques can be used by game developers.
In any case, what we have today with our new G96 based low end hardware doesn't rock the boat in any major ways. Yes it is faster than the previous part at this price (8500 GT), and yes it competes with previous generation mid-range hardware (8600 GT). But that just doesn't seem like much after the launch of GT200. Here's how it stacks up in terms of processing power:
| GeForce 8500 GT | GeForce 8600 GT | GeForce 9500 GT | |
| IC Codename | G86 | G84 | G96 |
| Fab Process | 80nm | 80nm | 65nm |
| Shader Pipes | 16 | 32 | 32 |
| Shader Clock | 900MHz | 1190MHz | 1400MHz |
| ROPs | 8 | 8 | 8 |
| Core Clock | 450MHz | 540MHz | 550MHz |
| Memory Bus Width | 128 bit | 128 bit | 128 bit |
| Memory Data Rate | 800MHz | 1400MHz | 1600MHz |
We can see that this is just another evolutionary low end part. Yes, volume is large, but apparently offering something that really improves value is out of the question.
The fact is that, traditionally, you get more (if not the most) for your money at the $200-$300 price point. Above this we see diminishing returns on performance per dollar, and below this you really just don't get what you pay for (even though you aren't spending much in some cases).
This needs to change. And it needs to change without diminishing what we get at the midrange. We aren't asking for higher return on your investment at lower prices, but we would love it if the value curve would flatten out a bit. Diminishing returns at the high end are fine (people will pay a premium for the top of the line) but it is just doubly insulting to sell us an under performing part and charge us way too much for the performance we do get.
We don't see any sign of change today, and we probably won't see any sort of major shift next time around either. But we will keep making noise when we have the opportunity. Maybe AMD's next mainstream launch will be a bit more interesting.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2612 (Wayback Machine).