Archive 1997–2024

AMD's Phenom X4 9950, 9350e and 9150e: Lower Prices, Voltage Tricks and Strange Behavior

3D Rendering Performance

3dsmax r9

Our benchmark, as always, is the SPECapc 3dsmax 8 test but for the purpose of this article we only run the CPU rendering tests and not the GPU tests.

The results are reported as render times in seconds and the final CPU composite score is a weighted geometric mean of all of the test scores.

3dsmax 9 - SPECapc CPU Rendering Benchmark

Overall performance in our 3dsmax test is quite favorable to AMD (mostly because of one very unique test, which we talk about below). The individual scores however show a very competitive showing by AMD, at least at these price points.

3dsmax 9 - SPECapc CPU Rendering Benchmark

Although hot on its heels, the Phenom X3 8650 is unable to outperform the E7200 here. The 9950 BE manages to pull slightly ahead of the Q9300 and the E8400 and 9550 are basically tied.



3dsmax 9 - SPECapc CPU Rendering Benchmark

This is the test that actually screws the whole thing for Intel. It turns out that CBALLS2 calls a function in the Microsoft C Runtime Library (msvcrt.dll) that, when combined with Vista SP1, can magnify the Core architecture's performance penalty when accessing data that is not aligned with cache line boundaries. This has been fixed in Nehalem, but until then this one 3dsmax test will suffer - giving AMD the advantage here, and making it far more competitive in the 3dsmax overall score.

3dsmax 9 - SPECapc CPU Rendering Benchmark

Intel inches ahead in the performance-per-dollar race here at all of the price points.

3dsmax 9 - SPECapc CPU Rendering Benchmark

3dsmax 9 - SPECapc CPU Rendering Benchmark

3dsmax 9 - SPECapc CPU Rendering Benchmark

3dsmax 9 - SPECapc CPU Rendering Benchmark

Cinebench R10

A benchmarking favorite, Cinebench R10 is designed to give us an indication of performance in the Cinema 4D rendering application.

Cinebench R10 - 1CPU Benchmark

Single core performance here is dismal for AMD, luckily you get more cores for the same money from AMD and thus once we look at multithreaded performance things change a bit:

Cinebench R10 - XCPU Benchmark

The 9950 is now nearly as fast as a Q6600, although Intel maintains the performance-per-dollar lead here. The 9550 manages to outperform the Core 2 Duo E8400 at the same price, simply due to the fact that it has more cores.

POV-Ray 3.7 Beta 24

POV-Ray is a popular raytracer, also available with a built in benchmark. We used the 3.7 beta which has SMP support and ran the built in multithreaded benchmark.

POV-Ray 3.7 Beta 24 - SMP CPU Benchmark

We see a similar breakdown in POV-Ray, AMD is competitive but it can't take any significant lead - cost is the only competitive leg it has to stand on here; thankfully it is one that supports Phenom's weight.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2559 (Wayback Machine).