Archive 1997–2024

Sigma SD14: Quick Look at a Quirky Wonder

SD14 Noise over ISO Range

Sigma and Foveon claim the SD14 is 14.06 effective megapixels. It is true that the Foveon image is composed of three dots (red, green, blue) per point, compared to one per point for the Bayer sensor used in other cameras. However, the finished Foveon image is 4.7MPx3 instead of the 10 to 14MP of competing cameras. Of course the extra pixels and the missing colors are interpolated on competing cameras where they are discrete on the SD14, which is why we see the 14.1MP claim. There is no point in taking sides in this argument. You can see and judge for yourself from results.

The output of the SD14 was compared to three other top prosumer cameras in the Olympus E3, Canon 40D, and Nikon D300. The chart below represents one-to-one pixel-level crops of the finished images.  Results for the other three cameras were first published in The Digital Sensor: Part 2 and you can go there by clicking the link for more information on how the images were captured.

The Sigma SD14 was a new challenge for this comparison. It is the first SD to offer JPEG capture but most users still consider that capability as somewhat unrefined compared to competing cameras. The SD14 is a RAW camera first that is really designed to be used in conjunction with your computer processing and converting images in Sigma Photo Pro for the PC or MAC. As a result all images were shot as RAW at the same f/4.0 with Incandescent White Balance that was used in competing tests. Images were then converted using Sigma Photo Pro 2.5 in Auto mode and saved as a large 16-bit TIFF. The Tiffs were processed in Photoshop CS3. The 120x200 pixel crops were captured from the TIFF and saved as a Maximum Quality JPEG so it could be displayed on the web.

Our website and most others do not support TIFF images for display, and certainly Foveon RAW is not supported.  PNG format would be an option, but PNG files can be 5 times larger than a comparable high quality JPEG with no real improvement in image quality.  Therefore the crop and full image were saved from the TIFF in the highest quality option available for JPEG files in the Save for Web option.

Wherever possible the images were captured using a 50mm f/1.4 normal lens. This represents an equivalent 35mm focal length of 75mm for the Nikon D60, and 80mm for the Canon 40D. A 50mm on the 4/3 cameras would have an equivalent 100mm field-of-view so images were captured using the 35mm Olympus Macro lens, which is equivalent to 70mm. This lens was chosen because it is critically sharp wide-open and is in its best resolution range at the standard f/4.0 capture aperture.

The SD14 images were captured with a Sigma 50mm f2.8 Macro lens I purchased many years ago with an SA-300N camera. It was and is a very good Macro lens and it worked perfectly on the SD14. Keep in mind the Sigma SD14 has a lens multiplier of 1.7x so it is equivalent to an 85mm lens on a 35mm camera. That accounts for a small portion of the field-of-view variations in the equal pixel crops. However, most of the difference is a result of the differing pixel size of the finished image

All images were captured at the same f/4.0 aperture using a tripod in the same location. Focus was manual and the camera program selected the shutter speed. Lighting was a single 100W Tungsten bulb high right, and all cameras were all set to the Tungsten (Incandescent) preset.

Sensor Performance
JPEG Comparison over ISO Range
ISO Sigma SD14
14.06MP

(4.7MP x 3)
Canon 40D
10.1MP
Olympus E3
10.1MP
Nikon D300
12.3MP
50      
100
200
400
800
1600
3200  
6400      

Click on any of the above image crops for the full image.
Note: Full size images are between 2.0MB and 5.8MB!


The Foveon is widely considered a low ISO sensor. In the second generation Foveon, most consider best performance is ISO 50 to ISO 200. There is no doubt in looking at the original RAW images that noise starts to become apparent at ISO 400 and it becomes pronounced at ISO 800. Looking at an ISO 1600, the noise in the RAW image makes it all but unusable. Our surprise, however, was that the latest version of Sigma Photo Pro 2.5 does a pretty decent job of minimizing noise as the images are saved to TIFF. 400 is certainly usable , as is 800 for all but large prints. ISO 1600 should be reserved for those situations when nothing else will produce an image.

The sweet spot for the Foveon is definitely ISO 50 to 200. Image quality is superb at those speeds, but 400 and 800 are also usable. The Foveon is not sensitive like some of the best of the current CMOS sensors. It is nowhere near the ISO range of those new sensors. However, it does reach lower, to ISO 50 in the latest firmware than its competitors. You will find ISO 50 as an extension on the Canon 5D and on other full-frame sensors, but it is a rare option on crop sensors.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2538 (Wayback Machine).