Intel's 8-core Skulltrail Platform: Close to Perfecting the Niche
- Posted in
- CPUs
Final Words
Intel's V8 platform was a niche product but it wasn't very well executed. Skulltrail fixes many of the problems posed by V8 and does so well enough that we don't have a problem recommending it, assuming you are running applications that can take advantage of it. Even heavy multitasking won't stress all 8 cores, you really need the right applications to tame this beast.
If there's one thing we noticed in our tests is that Skulltrail is made for 3D rendering. We saw consistent gains and good scaling in all of our 3D rendering tests. These corner cases are the perfect use for Skulltrail, but much like Apple's MacBook Air you have to keep in mind that the usefulness of this platform is very limited. In a year's time, Skulltrail will be well on the way to obsolescence. If you need the power, have the budget and you can deal with the fact that Nehalem will offer 8 cores in a single socket that you can't upgrade to, then Skulltrail is worth a look. If not, just settle on a QX9770 and be done with it.
The problem with Skulltrail is the something that also plagued Intel's original V8 platform: the use of Fully Buffered DIMMs. It's even more insulting on Skulltrail because there are only four DIMM slots on the motherboard; the entire point of FBD is to allow for higher memory clock speeds without reducing the number of memory slots on a motherboard. The problem is that Skulltrail doesn't actually offer any more memory slots than a desktop motherboard, nor does it run its memory any faster. Intel is using a technology that has absolutely no business being on this motherboard. You just end up with slower, more expensive and more power hungry memory.
There are two sides to every story and we can't just hate on Intel for this. From Intel's perspective the market for a Skulltrail system isn't that big, so it makes sense to reuse existing chipsets/technology rather than create an entirely new platform. The majority of the market will switch to 8 cores when you can get that many with a single CPU, Skulltrail just isn't an option. All of Intel's dual CPU chipsets are all made for the Xeon, which all use Fully Buffered DIMM.
Using a desktop chipset isn't an option either. If Intel were to allow desktop chipsets to work in multi-socket configurations it would hurt Xeon sales, a couple of Q6600s in a desktop motherboard would make for a killer server and ruin the point of the profit-heavy Xeon platform. So because Skulltrail is such a niche product, it has to use components that aren't exactly well suited for it. We understand why Intel made the choices it did, but that doesn't mean we can't complain about it.
Skulltrail is closer to perfection than Intel's V8 platform ever was, but it's still not quite there. Let us use desktop memory and Intel will have a winner on its hands.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2435 (Wayback Machine).