NVIDIA's 3-way SLI: Can we finally play Crysis?
- Posted in
- GPUs
Quad SLI Redux?
With the hardware requirements met, it's time to look at the software requirements. Currently, 3-way SLI is only supported under Windows Vista, not XP. Other than the OS stipulation, 3-way SLI isn't really any different from conventional 2-card SLI. Many of you will remember the ill fated Quad SLI product NVIDIA brought to market just under two years ago.
Quad SLI had three major problems that kept it from being a worthwhile product:
1) It relied on the 7950 GX2, which was a single card, dual GPU solution. The problem is that the each GPU on a 7950 GX2 was slower than a 7900 GTX. So a single 7950 GX2 was slower than a pair of 7900 GTXs. Quad SLI used two of these 7950 GX2s, so the performance improvement over a pair of 7900 GTXs wasn't all that great at its best.
2) The best performing games with Quad SLI used AFR (Alternate Frame Rendering) to divide up the rendering workload, where each GPU was responsible for rendering its own frame. The result is that GPU 1 would render frame 1, while GPU 2 would work on the next frame, GPU 3 would work on the third and GPU 4 would work on the fourth. DirectX 9 unfortunately only allowed for a 3-frame render ahead, meaning that this AFR mode wouldn't work. With the vast majority of games being DX titles, this posed a significant problem to Quad SLI performance.
3) The final issue with Quad SLI was that by the end of the year, G80 was out, and G80 was much faster. A pair of 8800 GTXs demolished a Quad SLI setup, and in some cases even a single card was faster.
Thankfully, 3-way SLI doesn't have these problems. The three-card SLI setup relies on regular 8800 GTX/Ultra cards, which are still among the fastest GPUs that NVIDIA offers today. The 3-frame render ahead limitations of DX9 aren't present in DX10, so we can get good scaling with AFR in DX10 titles.
The problem of planned obsolesce is a concern though and it's almost inevitable that 3-way SLI based on G80 will be replaced very soon. There's no doubt that NVIDIA will eventually replace the 8800 GTX and Ultra with G92 based variants, which will reduce power consumption and improve performance. The fact that G80 came out over a year ago should preclude any thoughts of purchasing a brand new 3-way SLI setup, but for users who already have two 8800 GTX or Ultra cards, adding a third is a mostly reasonable proposition.
The Test
Special thanks to both EVGA and ASUS for providing us with hardware for this review. Both EVGA and ASUS sent us 8800 Ultras and 780i based motherboards for this comparison, although it is worth mentioning that you could use a 680i motherboard and any brand (or mixture of brands) of 8800 GTX/Ultra cards - provide of course that your 680i motherboard has the necessary x16 PCIe slots.

| Test Setup | |
| CPU | Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 @ 3.33GHz |
| Motherboard | EVGA nForce 780i SLI |
| Video Cards | NVIDIA GeForce 8800 Ultra x 3 |
| Video Drivers | NVIDIA: 169.18 |
| Hard Drive | Seagate 7200.9 300GB 8MB 7200RPM |
| RAM | 4x1GB Corsair XMS2 DDR2-800 4-4-4-12 |
| Operating System | Windows Vista Ultimate 32-bit |
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2403 (Wayback Machine).