Archive 1997–2024

Mobile Platform Wars: AMD vs. Intel

AMD vs. AMD

We'll start with a quick look at how the TL-66 compares to the TL-60. AMD informed us that there are no major architectural changes to the 65nm processor, so any performance improvements should be directly attributable to the increased clock speed. As the TL-66 processor is clocked 15% faster, we shouldn't see any performance improvements larger than 15%, and bottlenecks elsewhere in the platform should keep the performance improvements closer to 10%.

Performance Comparison
  HP 6515b TL-60 HP 6515b TL-66 TL66 vs.TL60
DivX 6.6.1 (FPS) 5.10 5.71 11.9%
QuickTime 7.2 H.264 (FPS) 31.82 34.41 8.1%
WME9 Advanced (FPS) 32.10 37.11 15.6%
iTunes 7.4.2 MP3 192kbps (MB/s) 4.90 5.58 13.8%
Cinebench R10 (Score) 3189 3556 11.5%
SYSmark 2007 Overall 75.25 80.25 6.6%
SYSmark 2007 E-Learning 77 82 6.5%
SYSmark 2007 Video Creation 71 75 5.6%
SYSmark 2007 Productivity 69 71 2.9%
SYSmark 2007 3D 84 93 10.7%
MobileMark 2007 Productivity
Performance
125 140 12.0%
MobileMark 2007 Productivity
Battery
156 156 0.0%
MobileMark 2007 DVD Battery 127 131 3.1%
Average Performance Difference 9.6%

As expected, we see performance improvements across the board, and the overall average increase is pretty close to 10%. The pure number-crunching benchmarks show the largest performance increases, while benchmarks that stress all areas of the computer show smaller improvements. The latter is best represented by SYSmark 2007, and notice that the productivity suite in particular only shows a small 3% performance increase.

Besides performance changes, it's also interesting to note battery life. The TL-66 is faster than the TL-60, which is expected, but it also offers the same or slightly better battery life. This can be directly attributed to improvements in the process technology that lead to lower power use. While the differences aren't all that dramatic, improving performance by 10% without reducing battery life is always a good thing.

Now let's see how these two AMD processors to compare to a similar Intel Core 2 Duo chip.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2345/mobile-platform-wars-amd-vs-intel (Wayback Machine).