Low Power Server CPU Shoot-out
- Posted in
- IT Computing
Conclusion
Power is on everyone's mind these days and rightfully so. The cost of operating and cooling the average server is certainly not cheap, and is on the rise year over year. The question is whether the CPU is the component under the hood that is utilizing the majority of total system power or not. The answer to that question should be clear: the CPU is just a piece of the puzzle. Memory, fans, chipset, drives, HBAs, etc. all play a role in utilizing power.
AMD is clearly the leader when it comes to performance per watt using the workloads in this article. What is interesting to note is that AMD's advantage isn't at the processor level, but instead it's related to the fact that they don't use fully buffered DIMMs. Obviously, the measurements we took of each component aren't precise - it's just about impossible to do that (at least without sophisticated equipment). However, we can safely draw the conclusion that there is a lot more to power consumption than the CPU itself.
So should you run out and upgrade all of your servers to low voltage processors? We certainly can't answer that question without understanding your server workloads, budget, etc. If a few watts will make a large impact on your total operating cost, then the few hundred dollars per box may be justified. However, we think that more organizations should be thinking about power in terms of utilization.
How many of your servers are sitting around idling 90% of the time? Studies indicate that the average utilization of a PC based server is approximately 7%. Instead of investing a few hundred dollars in saving a few watts, why not try server consolidation? As you have seen the majority of system power is used just to run the fans, chipset, CPU, etc. when the server is at idle. If you could take two systems that consume 300 watts of power and combine them into one server, isn't that worth more to your organization? Take a look at VMWare, XenSource, and other virtualization solutions, if you really want to lower operating costs relating to power consumption.
Power is on everyone's mind these days and rightfully so. The cost of operating and cooling the average server is certainly not cheap, and is on the rise year over year. The question is whether the CPU is the component under the hood that is utilizing the majority of total system power or not. The answer to that question should be clear: the CPU is just a piece of the puzzle. Memory, fans, chipset, drives, HBAs, etc. all play a role in utilizing power.
AMD is clearly the leader when it comes to performance per watt using the workloads in this article. What is interesting to note is that AMD's advantage isn't at the processor level, but instead it's related to the fact that they don't use fully buffered DIMMs. Obviously, the measurements we took of each component aren't precise - it's just about impossible to do that (at least without sophisticated equipment). However, we can safely draw the conclusion that there is a lot more to power consumption than the CPU itself.
So should you run out and upgrade all of your servers to low voltage processors? We certainly can't answer that question without understanding your server workloads, budget, etc. If a few watts will make a large impact on your total operating cost, then the few hundred dollars per box may be justified. However, we think that more organizations should be thinking about power in terms of utilization.
How many of your servers are sitting around idling 90% of the time? Studies indicate that the average utilization of a PC based server is approximately 7%. Instead of investing a few hundred dollars in saving a few watts, why not try server consolidation? As you have seen the majority of system power is used just to run the fans, chipset, CPU, etc. when the server is at idle. If you could take two systems that consume 300 watts of power and combine them into one server, isn't that worth more to your organization? Take a look at VMWare, XenSource, and other virtualization solutions, if you really want to lower operating costs relating to power consumption.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2277 (Wayback Machine).