AMD Athlon X2 BE-2350: Mainstream X2s with 45W TDP
- Posted in
- CPUs
Final Words
The performance of the Athlon X2 BE-23xx lineup isn't particularly impressive, but that is to be expected. Power consumption is definitely down over the standard 65nm 65W Athlon 64 X2s, but not as low as the old 35W EE SFF parts were. A direct comparison to the Core 2 Duo E4300 is difficult given that we are forced to use different chipsets/motherboards, but for a high performance system you can easily build a comparably low power system out of Intel parts. AMD argues that with integrated graphics you can deliver a lower overall TDP on one of its systems, which we tend to believe given that the P965 is one of the lowest power Intel chipsets you can buy whereas the nForce 590 SLI that's a part of our normal AMD test bed is far from the lowest power offering out there. We will be looking at integrated graphics/platform performance in a future CPU article when we will address this topic in greater detail.
If you're simply looking for a high performance system with lower power requirements, possibly just to keep your office/room cooler and quieter, then the Core 2 Duo E4300 is still a better bet than either of these new X2s. You will pay about $25 more, but the increase in performance is more than tangible (not to mention the fact that you can actually get close to top of the line performance if you decide to overclock the E4300).
However, if performance isn't a primary concern and you're not interested in overclocking (our BE-2350 wouldn't even break 2.4GHz), then these chips offer an interesting alternative to current 65W X2s. The only issue is that you have to be committed to AMD's Socket-AM2 platform, which at this point we're not sure will give you a good upgrade path in the future (depending on how successful Phenom ends up being).
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2246 (Wayback Machine).