Archive 1997–2024

Supermicro's Twin: Two nodes and 16 cores in 1U

Analysis

The Supermicro Twin 1U combined with Intel's latest quad core technology offers an amazing amount of processing power in a 1U box. Just a bit more than two years ago, four cores in a 1U server was not a common setup. Now we get four times as many cores in the same space. Even better is that the second node increases power requirements by only 55%, while a second server would probably double the power needed. Considering the very competitive price, we can conclude that the Supermicro 1U Twin is probably the most attractive offer on the market today for those looking for a HPC node or rendering farm node.

The situation is different for the other markets that Supermicro targets: "data center and high-availability applications". What makes the 1U Twin so irresistible for the HPC and rendering people resulted in a few shortcomings for the HA applications, for example the heavy duty web applications. Although there is little doubt in our mind that Supermicro has used a high-quality, high-efficiency power supply, the fact remains that it is a single point of failure that can take down both nodes. Of course, with a decent UPS protection, you can take away the number one killer of power supplies: power surges. And it must be said that several studies have shown that failing hardware causes only 10% of the total downtime. About 50% of that, or 5% in total, is the result of a failed PSU. With a high quality PSU and a UPS with power surge protection, that percentage will be much lower. So it will depend on your own situation whether this is a risk you are willing to take. More than a third of the downtime is caused by software problems, and another third is planned downtime for upgrades and similar tasks. Those are downtimes that the Supermicro Twin with its two nodes is capable of avoiding with software techniques such as NLB and other forms of clustering.

A lot of the SMBs we are working with are looking collocate their HA applications servers and would love to run two web (NLB) and database servers (clustered) in only 2U. Right now, those servers typically take 4U and 6U, and the Supermicro twin could reduce those collocation costs considerably.

The biggest shortcoming is one that can probably be easily resolved by Supermicro: the lack of an SAS controller. It is not the higher performance of SAS that makes us say that, but VMWare's lack of support for SATA drives and controllers. A few Supermicro Twin 1U together with a shared storage solution (FC SAN, iSCSI SAN) could be an ideal platform to virtualize: you could run a lot of virtual nodes on the different physical nodes which results in consolidation and thus cost reduction, and the physical nodes offer high availability. However, VMWare ESX server does not support SATA controllers very well, so booting from a SAN is then the only option, which increases the complexity of the setup. A SAS controller would allow users to boot from two mirrored disks.

A SAS controller and a redundant power supply would make the Supermicro Twin 1U close to perfect. But let's be fair: the Supermicro Server Twin 1U is an amazing product for its primary market. It's not every day that we meet a 16 core server which saves you 100W of power and cuts rack space collocation in half... all for a very competitive price. Also, two nodes each with eight cores will remain a very interesting solution for applications such as rendering farms even when the quad core Xeon MP ("Tigerton") and AMD's quad core Opteron ("Barcelona") arrive. The reason is that performance will be competitive and that the price of four socket quad core systems will almost certainly be quite high. The Supermicro Twin 1U is an interesting idea which has materialized in an excellent product.

Advantages:
  • Cuts necessary rack space in half, superb computing density
  • Very high performance/power ratio, simply superior power supply
  • Highest performance/price ratio today
  • Excellent track record of Supermicro
Disadvantages:
  • No SAS controller (for now?)
  • Hard to virtualize with ESX server
  • Cold swap PSU

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2240 (Wayback Machine).