Archive 1997–2024

The Future of Anti-Aliasing Settings in Question: NVIDIA Discussion

Final Words

Driver AA settings are getting too complicated and unpredictable. It would be terrific if all game developers could support AA settings in-game or through the driver, but that just isn't a reality. Moving forward, as programmable techniques mature standard MSAA may prove more and more difficult to force on across the board through a driver. For NVIDIA, the complications of maintaining driver controlled CSAA and MSAA are numerous. The impact on the end user is that AA may or may not function in the expected way, causing headaches for the gamer, hardware maker and software designer.

From our perspective, the informational approach through a warning when AA settings are changed is great, but could be subject to the Windows user "just click OK" mentality. Educating the average gamer on the possibilities is something we can get behind, but we just aren't sure that this approach would work. Even so, we wouldn't mind seeing this implemented, especially if we have an option to avoid seeing the pop-up once its been shown once.

Profiles don't seem like the right fit, as it can be cumbersome to manage settings for each game on a computer both in the game and in the driver. Perhaps if profiles gain in popularity this could be the way to go, but we feel there is a better solution.

Implementing a coolbits-like feature to enable override AA in general driver settings seems like the best way to go. This could even be combined with the warning box idea without a problem. This would both encourage the use of in-game settings through the removal of the driver option from the default install and provide the possibility of educating users who discover how to enable the option.

In addition to providing feedback on what NVIDIA should do, we are interested in the way our readers currently tackle AA. In testing, we use in-game settings exclusively when available. What method do you use to set AA?

As we mentioned, NVIDIA has not decided that any of these actions are necessary at this point. This article is meant to open a discussion on the best possible way to proceed, and your feedback is important. If we all have the goal of maximizing customizability and accessibility without causing problems for the majority of users, we will be in a very good place indeed.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2191 (Wayback Machine).