Archive 1997–2024

SMB NAS Roundup

Conclusion

We had a hard time naming a true winner in this roundup. When we generated the feature list to compare these units side-by-side, we started to realize that what we really had are two different types of devices. First we have devices that cater to the home user who wants multimedia and ease-of-use features. Second we have devices that cater to small businesses that desire more security and network features.

None of these devices broke any land speed records (except for the Hammer), which we hope vendors will fix in the future. Although the Hammer unit peaked at over 70 Megabytes per second, it did so using nearly 70% of the CPU on the client accessing it. We think this is entirely too high, and some optimization on the client software needs to be performed. Still, assuming your CPU is generally sitting idle (which is often the case), some people will be happy to sacrifice CPU usage for increased speeds. The Infrant device was the best performer out of the rest of the devices, followed by LaCie, Thecus and QNAP.

Home

We selected the Infrant NV+ device as the winner in the home category, due to its performance and feature set. Infrant had an extensive feature set targeted at the home user, which included features like a DHCP Server, UPnP, USB Device Support, and Streaming services.

Business

The QNAP TS401-T unit was the clear winner for the Business market. The features that stood out are the optional redundant power, redundant NICs, UPS support, SNMP support, Network Printer Sharing, CD/DVD Backup, Active Directory Integration, and Quotas.

 

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2127 (Wayback Machine).