Archive 1997–2024

AMD's Quad FX: Technically Quad Core

Four cores, 1 Socket or Four cores, 2 Sockets?

One of the major arguments in favor of AMD's Quad FX architecture is the fact that you should get better performance scaling when going from 2 to 4 cores since there's no FSB limiting the data coming in to the CPUs. We looked at the performance scaling from a single FX-74 to two FX-74 processors in our Quad FX platform and compared it to Intel's Core 2 running at 2.66GHz with two and four cores enabled.

 Benchmark AMD Scaling (2 to 4 cores) Intel Scaling (2 to 4 cores)
3dsmax 8 64.7% 77.0%
Cinebench 75.6% 70.8%
DivX 6.4 29.5% 35.0%
WME9 53.2% 54.8%
Blu-ray + Cinebench 147% 135%
Blu-ray + DivX 43.9% 48.3%
Blu-ray + WME 65.4% 73.4%
Blu-ray + 3dsmax 8 63.1% 77.0%
Valve Particle Systems 48.8% 93.1%
Valve Map Compilation 42.0% 44.3%

 

Even when we take into account our heavy multitasking Blu-ray playback scenarios (which we will describe later), AMD's Quad FX doesn't scale any better than Intel's quad-core solution. All things being equal, AMD should have better scaling, however AMD's cores are inherently slower in most of these benchmarks and thus simply adding more of them is not going to make up for the deficit seen by one.

AMD will have better scaling on paper, but Intel has the superior micro-architecture today, which results in better performance and in most cases, better scaling than AMD. The same might not be true in the enterprise market, but we'll have to save that for a look at Opteron vs. Xeon.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2125 (Wayback Machine).