Super Talent & TEAM Join the Fast DDR2 Club
- Posted in
- Memory
Final Words
Our first encounter with the new Micron D memory chips came with our review of OCZ EL PC2-8000 XTC in early spring. We were impressed with the performance then, and our admiration for the performance capabilities of this DDR2 chip has only grown since. This was the fastest DDR2 memory ever tested at AnandTech, and it also scaled easily to the new DDR2-800 speed to be supported by AM2 and Conroe, on to the DDR2-1067 future speed, and beyond to DDR2-1100. It reached those levels at the fastest memory timings we had seen with DDR2. This DDR2 memory was clearly the new DDR2 standard and we awarded the OCZ EL PC2-8000 XTC our Gold Editors Choice.
With the subsequent launch of AMD AM2 and the launch of the Intel Core 2 Duo, memory based on Micron memory chips has benefited even more. AM2 was not really much of a performance boost, but the DDR2 memory scales very well on AM2. Core 2 Duo does not make as much use of the DDR2 bandwidth as AM2, but it frankly doesn't need it. Core 2 Duo has turned out to be one of the largest performance increases we have ever seen with a new processor, and the brute performance strength of C2D more than offsets any memory performance advantage for AM2. AM2 is clearly a better memory platform in raw bandwidth than Core 2 Duo, and that fact may come back into play in the future. For now it is a moot point.
In the past two months memory prices have increased significantly. For that reason alone, buyers are looking much more closely at memory prices and comparison-shopping. The two memories tested here, the Super Talent DDR2-1000 and the TEAM DDR2-1000, are both an excellent choice in your comparison shopping. In general they perform just as well as the most expensive DDR2 at the critical DDR2-800 and DDR2-667 speeds, running with stability at 3-3-3 and 3-2-3 timings, just like the top DDR2 memory. While neither will overclock quite as far as the top memory we have tested, both do reach DDR2-1067 with ease. While they top out at 1080/1084, the practical difference between these top speeds and 1100+ is pretty minimal. The message here is if you can find Super Talent or TEAM at a cheaper price than the other top DDR2-1000 and up brands then buy it. You will get good value.
There is one caveat, however. The TEAM is definitely the better performer of the two tested brands. It requires a little less voltage at each speed for stability, and it matches the timings of the best DDR2 we have ever tested at all the stock speeds. The Super Talent performs much the same at 667 and 800, but it requires slightly slower timings at DDR2-1067. Therefore if you plan to run your memory at DDR2-1067 choose TEAM or another top DDR2 instead.
It is fair to ask if there is any real reason to run your memory faster than DDR2-800. The answer is Yes, provided your memory is capable of 4-3-4 timings at 1067 like the top memory we have tested. There are small but real performance advantages for any of these memories running at DDR2-1067, as you can see in the performance charts. 4-3-4 timings at 1067 is fast enough to make the 1067 speed a performance advantage, and the TEAM DDR2-1067 and the other top DDR2 memories can run at these timings with complete stability at 2.2V to 2.4V.
When we looked at High-Performance DDR2 in the Conroe Buying Guide, it was clear that the performance we first saw with the OCZ EL PC2-8000 was now available from a wider group of memory manufacturers. OCZ, Corsair, and Mushkin stood out at the top of the group of six, but frankly any of the six could deliver the kind of performance that could make a difference in a top Core 2 or AM2 system. That included the 2GB kits from Buffalo, Kingston, and Crucial. You can now add TEAM to that group of top performers, with Super Talent just an SPD upgrade away from the same level of performance. With memory prices high, this gives you a wide range of brands that will generally satisfy in your quest for the best performance you can achieve in computing.
The TEAM and Super Talent will not displace our top two performers in recent tests - the Corsair 6400C3 and the OCZ Ti Alpha PC2-8000 VX2 both use special binning of these Micron memory chips to push performance and overclocking up another level. The advantage for these two is not huge, but it is definitely real. But just below the absolute best there are now many brands that will bring you competitive memory performance up to DDR2-1067. TEAM and Super Talent join that group.
Our first encounter with the new Micron D memory chips came with our review of OCZ EL PC2-8000 XTC in early spring. We were impressed with the performance then, and our admiration for the performance capabilities of this DDR2 chip has only grown since. This was the fastest DDR2 memory ever tested at AnandTech, and it also scaled easily to the new DDR2-800 speed to be supported by AM2 and Conroe, on to the DDR2-1067 future speed, and beyond to DDR2-1100. It reached those levels at the fastest memory timings we had seen with DDR2. This DDR2 memory was clearly the new DDR2 standard and we awarded the OCZ EL PC2-8000 XTC our Gold Editors Choice.
With the subsequent launch of AMD AM2 and the launch of the Intel Core 2 Duo, memory based on Micron memory chips has benefited even more. AM2 was not really much of a performance boost, but the DDR2 memory scales very well on AM2. Core 2 Duo does not make as much use of the DDR2 bandwidth as AM2, but it frankly doesn't need it. Core 2 Duo has turned out to be one of the largest performance increases we have ever seen with a new processor, and the brute performance strength of C2D more than offsets any memory performance advantage for AM2. AM2 is clearly a better memory platform in raw bandwidth than Core 2 Duo, and that fact may come back into play in the future. For now it is a moot point.
In the past two months memory prices have increased significantly. For that reason alone, buyers are looking much more closely at memory prices and comparison-shopping. The two memories tested here, the Super Talent DDR2-1000 and the TEAM DDR2-1000, are both an excellent choice in your comparison shopping. In general they perform just as well as the most expensive DDR2 at the critical DDR2-800 and DDR2-667 speeds, running with stability at 3-3-3 and 3-2-3 timings, just like the top DDR2 memory. While neither will overclock quite as far as the top memory we have tested, both do reach DDR2-1067 with ease. While they top out at 1080/1084, the practical difference between these top speeds and 1100+ is pretty minimal. The message here is if you can find Super Talent or TEAM at a cheaper price than the other top DDR2-1000 and up brands then buy it. You will get good value.
There is one caveat, however. The TEAM is definitely the better performer of the two tested brands. It requires a little less voltage at each speed for stability, and it matches the timings of the best DDR2 we have ever tested at all the stock speeds. The Super Talent performs much the same at 667 and 800, but it requires slightly slower timings at DDR2-1067. Therefore if you plan to run your memory at DDR2-1067 choose TEAM or another top DDR2 instead.
It is fair to ask if there is any real reason to run your memory faster than DDR2-800. The answer is Yes, provided your memory is capable of 4-3-4 timings at 1067 like the top memory we have tested. There are small but real performance advantages for any of these memories running at DDR2-1067, as you can see in the performance charts. 4-3-4 timings at 1067 is fast enough to make the 1067 speed a performance advantage, and the TEAM DDR2-1067 and the other top DDR2 memories can run at these timings with complete stability at 2.2V to 2.4V.
When we looked at High-Performance DDR2 in the Conroe Buying Guide, it was clear that the performance we first saw with the OCZ EL PC2-8000 was now available from a wider group of memory manufacturers. OCZ, Corsair, and Mushkin stood out at the top of the group of six, but frankly any of the six could deliver the kind of performance that could make a difference in a top Core 2 or AM2 system. That included the 2GB kits from Buffalo, Kingston, and Crucial. You can now add TEAM to that group of top performers, with Super Talent just an SPD upgrade away from the same level of performance. With memory prices high, this gives you a wide range of brands that will generally satisfy in your quest for the best performance you can achieve in computing.
The TEAM and Super Talent will not displace our top two performers in recent tests - the Corsair 6400C3 and the OCZ Ti Alpha PC2-8000 VX2 both use special binning of these Micron memory chips to push performance and overclocking up another level. The advantage for these two is not huge, but it is definitely real. But just below the absolute best there are now many brands that will bring you competitive memory performance up to DDR2-1067. TEAM and Super Talent join that group.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/2099 (Wayback Machine).