Archive 1997–2024

Flash Media: 1GB CompactFlash Roundup

SiSoft Sandra File System Benchmark

SiSoft Sandra does things a little different than HDTach 3 RW. The results reported here refer to the number of operations per minute while working with the various sizes of chunks of data. The final "Combined Index" value refers to the "combined performance in terms of Combined Operations Per Second, with respect to a mix of write, read and delete operations" across all of the tested file sizes.

The number we see for the "Endurance Factor" represents the overall "Wear and Life Expectancy" of the flash media. The fact of the matter is that flash media can be written to only so many times. Upon each write, some amount of wear occurs which cause performance degradation and eventually, though not so quickly, failure of the media. SiSoft Sandra calculates the "Endurance Factor" by dividing the average performance, for example a sequential write, by the lowest performance, a rewrite of the same block of data initially written to. For all of the values, high is always better.

SiSoft Sandra Removable Storage/Flash Benchmark
Operations per second
512B 32KB 256KB 2MB 64MB Combined Index Endurance Factor
EDGE 1885 1659 866 161 6 1509 14.0
Kingston 351 331 242 33 2 299 38.2
Lexar 4699 3853 1355 194 7 3543 7.6
PNY 650 613 464 71 5 556 19.3
PQI 240 230 197 78 3 215 42.7
RiData 1080 1000 676 87 6 903 32.4
Rosewill 240 231 200 79 3 216 43.3
SanDisk 470 439 349 94 7 407 43.5
Transcend 1588 1428 849 127 7 1296 8.9
Viking 245 236 206 81 3 221 45.0


As far as performance goes, Lexar's Professional series CompactFlash media takes the gold with its combined index of 3543 operations per minute but its overall life expectancy is not much to drool about. The values should be compared not to any outside standard but only to the other media on this list and it looks like Viking's standard CompactFlash model is going to outlive the rest of these devices. In fact, none of the top performers look like they will live as long as the lower performing cards. We assume this is because the high performance products perform a lot more read, write, and erase operations on average compared to the lower end cards. It is a simple trade-off between performance and life expectancy.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1906 (Wayback Machine).