Hitachi vs. Western Digital vs. Seagate: A Battle of the Mammoths
- Posted in
- Storage
Real World Tests - Multitasking Performance
To provide a real world example of multitasking, we run Outlook and import 450MB of emails into an account. We then measure the time that it takes our benchmarking utility to zip a single 300MB file. To compare our results, we calculate the difference between the multitasked process and the single task file zip process.
To provide a real world example of multitasking, we run Outlook and import 450MB of emails into an account. We then measure the time that it takes our benchmarking utility to zip a single 300MB file. To compare our results, we calculate the difference between the multitasked process and the single task file zip process.
| Outlook + Zip a 300MB File Within Drive | |||
| Multitasked | File Zip Only | % Difference | |
| Seagate 7200.9 500GB, 16MB, 3.0GB/sec | 69.215 | 59.707 | 15.9% |
| Hitachi 7K500, 16MB, 3.0GB/sec | 70.512 | 62.156 | 13.4% |
| Western Digital WD1600JS | 69.25 | 61.443 | 12.7% |
The WD4000YR looks like it performs the best out of the three while running multiple tasks but only by a second or two. It zips a 300MB file while importing emails in Outlook about 12.7% slower than just performing the file zip operation on its own while the Hitachi and Seagate drives handle this task 13.4-15.9% slower.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1881 (Wayback Machine).