Archive 1997–2024

Hitachi vs. Western Digital vs. Seagate: A Battle of the Mammoths

HDTach - Sequential Read Speed/Burst Speed

The HDTach benchmark gives us a great deal of detail on the performance of a hard drive. Like the WinBench 99 Transfer Rate test, HDTach graphs the sequential read speed of the drive as the drive reads continuously from beginning to end.

Seagate 500GB 7200.9


Click to enlarge.

Hitachi 7K500


Click to enlarge.

Western Digital WD4000YR


Click to enlarge.

The 500GB 7200.9 redeems itself here with the highest burst speed of 248.1MB/sec with the 7K500 coming in second at 223.6MB/sec. The rest of the figures here are all over the board with the 7K500 holding the lowest random access time at 12.6ms and the WD4000YR having the highest average read rate of 56.9MB/sec. We are obviously not ready to call a winner after only a few tests.

Windows Read Speed Test

Seagate 500GB 7200.9

IPEAK Business Winstone 2004 - Pure Hard Disk Performance

Hitachi 7K500

IPEAK Business Winstone 2004 - Pure Hard Disk Performance

Western Digital WD4000YR

IPEAK Business Winstone 2004 - Pure Hard Disk Performance



It seems the Windows Read Speed Test gives us a better readout of the actual transfer rates of each drive. We see that the Seagate and Hitachi read speeds are off the charts because of their 3.0Gb/sec maximum transfer rate. The WD4000YR is a 1.5Gb/sec drive which is why the transfer rate is much lower than the 7K500's 200MB/sec+ rate.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1881 (Wayback Machine).