Itanium - is there light at the end of the tunnel?
- Posted in
- CPUs
The benefits of TLP...
It is clear that the Itanium core has a big advantage in the area of threading and power dissipation constraints. If you are not convinced, the dual core Itanium Montecito (90 nm process) has no less than 1.72 billion transistors, but it is still able to consume less than 130 W. Compare this with the 300 million transistor Power 5+, which consumes about 170 W on a 90 nm SOI process.
And there is more. X86 CPUs are limited to a maximum of 3 decoded, issued and retired instructions. This might increase to 4 next year. But compared to the best x86 design today - the AMD Opteron -, the Itanium does about 60% more work per clock cycle in integer, and about 115% more work per cycle in floating point. Don't get me wrong, these numbers are no indication of superiority of any kind - clock speed matters just as much. But what these numbers tell you is that x86 designs are less brainiac in nature, and that the x86 ISA limits the ILP much more than IA-64 (we will give more proof in a later article). x86 designs prefer the speed-demon approach with deeper pipelines.
The Itanium can sustain 6 instructions per cycle and can issue up to 11 instructions. A lot of this potential goes to waste, but it also means that the potential gains for Multi-Threading techniques are much higher. While the Pentium 4 Xeon was unable to show any significant performance advantage due to SMT in our server tests[4], Montecito is claimed to be 30% faster in typical database loads, thanks to a Coarse Multi-Threading technique that is less advanced than Hyper Threading.
Itanium's future...
There is no doubt about it, the delay of Montecito and Intel's poor execution is a serious blow to the Itanium family. The Montecito based Itanium 2 has the features that it needs to be competitive in the server world for the next years: dual core, multi-threading and virtualization (Silverdale). Without these features, Itanium is hopelessly behind the competition, especially the dual core Xeon, Opteron and Power 5+. The Xeon and Opteron might still be a bit behind on the RAS features, but this can change quickly and is only important for a small part of the market.
If we ignore Intel's poor execution during the past months and the economic realities, and focus on the architecture, it is clear, however, that the Itanium has time on its side and is most likely the architecture with the highest potential.
Although the Itanium is capable of sustaining a theoretical maximum of 6 instructions and executing up to 11 instructions, and despite its massive register set, it uses fewer transistors for its core than all competitors. The main disadvantage is that it needs much more cache and instruction fetch width, but the disadvantage of needing more cache diminish as process technology gets better (smaller). To improve performance, the Itanium needs much bigger caches than its competitors, but this adds very little to the overall power consumption. As superscalar RISCs in x86 competitors increase their instruction execution width, they need to upgrade the Out-Of-Order buffers and more importantly, increase the complexity of the schedulers. This leads to a much higher complexity and power consumption.
As the focus shifts to Thread Level Parallellism, the Itanium's small cores make it easier to use more cores without increasing the power consumption too much. Montecito will be the living proof of this. The Itanium is also wider than the competition, which results in bigger benefits from threading techniques.
While Itanium may not be very popular in the hardware enthusiast community, it is definitely an architecture that, from an academic and technical point of view, deserves a lot more attention. We'll delve deeper in upcoming articles.
References
[1] The Quest for More Processing Power, Part One: "Is the single core CPU doomed?"
http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2343
[2] Hyper-Threading Technology Architecture and Microarchitecture
http://www.intel.com/technology/itj/2002/volume06issue01/art01_hyper/p01_abstract.htm
[3] Ace's hardware Specmine
http://www.aceshardware.com/SPECmine/
[4] Linux database server CPU comparison
http://www.anandtech.com/IT/showdoc.aspx?i=2447
It is clear that the Itanium core has a big advantage in the area of threading and power dissipation constraints. If you are not convinced, the dual core Itanium Montecito (90 nm process) has no less than 1.72 billion transistors, but it is still able to consume less than 130 W. Compare this with the 300 million transistor Power 5+, which consumes about 170 W on a 90 nm SOI process.
And there is more. X86 CPUs are limited to a maximum of 3 decoded, issued and retired instructions. This might increase to 4 next year. But compared to the best x86 design today - the AMD Opteron -, the Itanium does about 60% more work per clock cycle in integer, and about 115% more work per cycle in floating point. Don't get me wrong, these numbers are no indication of superiority of any kind - clock speed matters just as much. But what these numbers tell you is that x86 designs are less brainiac in nature, and that the x86 ISA limits the ILP much more than IA-64 (we will give more proof in a later article). x86 designs prefer the speed-demon approach with deeper pipelines.
The Itanium can sustain 6 instructions per cycle and can issue up to 11 instructions. A lot of this potential goes to waste, but it also means that the potential gains for Multi-Threading techniques are much higher. While the Pentium 4 Xeon was unable to show any significant performance advantage due to SMT in our server tests[4], Montecito is claimed to be 30% faster in typical database loads, thanks to a Coarse Multi-Threading technique that is less advanced than Hyper Threading.
Itanium's future...
There is no doubt about it, the delay of Montecito and Intel's poor execution is a serious blow to the Itanium family. The Montecito based Itanium 2 has the features that it needs to be competitive in the server world for the next years: dual core, multi-threading and virtualization (Silverdale). Without these features, Itanium is hopelessly behind the competition, especially the dual core Xeon, Opteron and Power 5+. The Xeon and Opteron might still be a bit behind on the RAS features, but this can change quickly and is only important for a small part of the market.
If we ignore Intel's poor execution during the past months and the economic realities, and focus on the architecture, it is clear, however, that the Itanium has time on its side and is most likely the architecture with the highest potential.
Although the Itanium is capable of sustaining a theoretical maximum of 6 instructions and executing up to 11 instructions, and despite its massive register set, it uses fewer transistors for its core than all competitors. The main disadvantage is that it needs much more cache and instruction fetch width, but the disadvantage of needing more cache diminish as process technology gets better (smaller). To improve performance, the Itanium needs much bigger caches than its competitors, but this adds very little to the overall power consumption. As superscalar RISCs in x86 competitors increase their instruction execution width, they need to upgrade the Out-Of-Order buffers and more importantly, increase the complexity of the schedulers. This leads to a much higher complexity and power consumption.
As the focus shifts to Thread Level Parallellism, the Itanium's small cores make it easier to use more cores without increasing the power consumption too much. Montecito will be the living proof of this. The Itanium is also wider than the competition, which results in bigger benefits from threading techniques.
While Itanium may not be very popular in the hardware enthusiast community, it is definitely an architecture that, from an academic and technical point of view, deserves a lot more attention. We'll delve deeper in upcoming articles.
References
[1] The Quest for More Processing Power, Part One: "Is the single core CPU doomed?"
http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2343
[2] Hyper-Threading Technology Architecture and Microarchitecture
http://www.intel.com/technology/itj/2002/volume06issue01/art01_hyper/p01_abstract.htm
[3] Ace's hardware Specmine
http://www.aceshardware.com/SPECmine/
[4] Linux database server CPU comparison
http://www.anandtech.com/IT/showdoc.aspx?i=2447
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1854 (Wayback Machine).