Archive 1997–2024

Price Guides, October 2005: Storage

SATA – 1.5Gbps

The real world difference in performance between SATA 3.0Gbps and SATA 1.5Gbps is difficult to gauge. In our initial tests, it was faster in some applications and slower in others. Depending on price and other features, SATA 1.5Gbps drives are still worth purchasing. We have a fairly nice deal on a Maxtor 160GB with a 16MB cache [RTPE: 6B250S0] for $0.40 per GB, totaling $99.00 shipped. Maxtor's drives aren't necessarily the quietest out there, but performance of the 16MB cache models is very good. Nevertheless, we’ve witnessed a steady decline in price with this particular Maxtor hard drive, which you can clearly see from this chart:


Maxtor 1.5Gbps 250GB 7200RPM 16MB DiamondMax 10

Presently, the 250GB SATA drives are hovering in the vicinity of $0.40 per GB, which is a bit cheaper than SATA II models. The least expensive model is the Maxtor MaxLine Plus II 8MB drive, but we'd avoid that particular drive. It's noisier than the newer Maxtor DiamondMax 10, and it doesn't have 16MB of cache.



We found that TigerDirect is running a $60 rebate on the Seagate 300GB Barracuda [RTPE: ST3300831AS], bringing the price down to $103.00 shipped. With the rebate, that gives an incredible cost of just $0.34/GB, though it's only a mediocre $0.51/GB without the MIR. The Seagate drives are well regarded in the computing community and come with a standard 5-year warranty, and this is the cheapest price that we’ve seen on this drive. You also get NCQ, so the only thing that you're missing relative to the 7200.9 model is support for higher burst rates and more cache.


Seagate 1.5Gbps 300GB 7200RPM 8MB Barracuda 7200.8



Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1823 (Wayback Machine).