Archive 1997–2024

ATI's Avivo vs. NVIDIA's PureVideo: De-Interlacing Quality Compared

A New Video Quality Benchmark: HQV

HQV, a high end video processor manufacturer, has released an excellent benchmark for evaluating the image quality of consumer electronics and PC based video products.  The HQV Benchmark DVD is a collection of tests that stress various aspects of motion video quality, with the goal of offering a standard by which video quality can be judged. 

In the past, we've used a handful of problematic DVDs to judge items like de-interlacing quality, but with HQV, we're not only able to replace those DVDs, but we're able to compare de-interlacing algorithms in a much more scientific manner, and for a wider range of scenarios. 

The benchmark is a simple DVD with a bunch of video sequences that each test a different feature that a high quality video setup should implement.  Each video sequence is accompanied with a list of things for which to look, as well as guidelines of how to rate a particular platform's success in playing the videoproperly.  Each test is subjectively rated and given a score from 0 - 10, higher being better.  Most tests can only be rated a "0" for failing, "5" for completing some of the requirements of the test, and a "10" for being perfect. 

The HQV Benchmark DVD is available for public purchase, and documentation is available on each of the tests that the benchmark runs.  The benchmark also provides guidelines on how to subjectively rate each test so that the results may be reproducible and scientific at the same time, despite their subjective nature.

Test Hardware

CPU: AMD Athlon 64 X2 4200+ (2.2GHz/512KBx2)
Motherboard: ASUS A8N-SLI Deluxe
Motherboard BIOS: ASUS: Version 1013 Dated 08/10/2005
Chipset: NVIDIA nForce4 SLI
Chipset Drivers: nForce4 6.66
Memory: OCZ PC3500 DDR 2-2-2-7
Video Card: ATI Radeon X1600 XT
NVIDIA GeForce 7800GTX
Video Drivers: ATI Catalyst 8.173.1.2
NVIDIA ForceWare 81.82
Desktop Resolution: 1600 x 1200 - 32-bit @ 60Hz
OS: Windows XP Professional SP2
Benchmarking Software: HQV Benchmark DVD
DVD Decoder: NVIDIA PureVideo 1.02-150

Note that we verified that ATI's image quality was the same whether we used NVIDIA's PureVideo DVD decoder or Intervideo's DVD decoder. We chose to benchmark with NVIDIA's PureVideo decoder in order to minimize the number of variables between cards.

Also note that we are only comparing ATI's X1600 XT to NVIDIA's GeForce 7800GTX. We have already compared NVIDIA's GeForce6/7 series of GPUs to ATI's previous generation of GPUs and determined that NVIDIA offered superior de-interlacing quality, so today's comparison will focus on the latest and greatest from both vendors to see if those standings have changed. Remember that the X1600 XT has the same de-interlacing engine as the X1300 and X1800, so the results here are directly applicable to all of ATI's new GPUs.

Both the ATI and NVIDIA drivers were set to auto-detect what de-interlacing algorithm the hardware should use. We found that this setting yielded the best results for each platform in the HQV benchmark.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1809 (Wayback Machine).