Archive 1997–2024

Seagate 120GB External Storage

WinBench 99

We have extended our WinBench 99 portion of our benchmarks to include not only the Disk Transfer Rate tests, but also a handful of other disk performance related tests, including Disk Access Time, CPU Utilization, Disk Playback/Bus, Disk Playback/HE, and Disk Playback/Removable Media. As we present our results, we will explain how each test is relevant in our methodology.

Disk Transfer Rate

In the past, we have just given the beginning and ending transfer rates, which doesn’t really show the performance of the entire disk because there is so much more in between on which we don’t report. Our new method includes a graph:


Click to enlarge.

The transfer rates remained constant at around 27MB/sec, which is about 7MB/sec lower than the E5’s ( AcomData) average transfer rate over the course of the disk. We checked our drivers and made sure that everything in our test bed was the same in testing both the E5 and Seagate’s 120GB unit and are confident of our results.

Disk Access Time

According to WinBench 99, the disk access time on the Seagate is 15ms, which is 1.8ms slower than the Western Digital carrying AcomData. We may be seeing a trend here as the larger 320GB Western Digital based E5 is performing much quicker in the synthetic tests so far.

WinBench 99 - Disk Access Time

Disk CPU Utilization

When testing the AcomData E5, we saw that CPU consumption was about 79.3% while transferring data over the USB interface. The Seagate drive took up less of the CPU’s time as it only consumed an average of 70.3% over its one and only USB interface.

WinBench 99 - Disk CPU Utilization

After working with the AcomData and the Seagate on a daily basis, we noticed this difference in CPU usage while transferring files back and forth and using other applications. While performing daily tasks such as checking Outlook email or editing images with Photoshop, we noticed a heaviness in processes while watching videos off of each of the external units over the USB interface. This is because the USB interface is dependent on the CPU whereas the FireWire interface is a peer-to-peer technology, which we mentioned during our look at the E5 last month.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1802 (Wayback Machine).