Seagate 120GB External Storage
- Posted in
- Storage
Final Thoughts
There really isn't a huge performance difference in these two drives when we look at the real world file system tests. The greatest differences, as small as they are, lay in the synthetic test results. Since the bottleneck of these external drives is the interface with which they communicate, USB 2.0 in the case of both drives in this comparison, there shouldn't be much of a performance difference.
However, we saw that the results of WinBench 99's Transfer Rate test and HDTach's Sequential read test show lower transfer and read speeds with the Seagate drive compared to the E5. The Disk Access time was also 1.8ms slower than the E5, at 15ms.
The 120GB Seagate drive is geared more towards those who just want to easily add a small amount of disk space to their systems. For daily backups and standard archival, any USB or FireWire based drive is a great addition to your desktop environment and Seagate creates a decent, stackable product with simple features that will appeal to all types of users.
Seagate's other external drives include FireWire and push button backup capabilities with capacities currently up to 400GB. The 120GB version comes at a cost in the sub-$100 range while the 300GB version, which has the Firewire interface along with the USB 2.0 interface, as well as the single button backup, runs between $200-$250 on average at most places. The 320GB E5 is seen as low as $222 at some online retailers and it features both Push Button backup as well as the FireWire 400 interface. Depending on your daily needs, the prices are at about the same level for the drive capacity and features they offer.
There really isn't a huge performance difference in these two drives when we look at the real world file system tests. The greatest differences, as small as they are, lay in the synthetic test results. Since the bottleneck of these external drives is the interface with which they communicate, USB 2.0 in the case of both drives in this comparison, there shouldn't be much of a performance difference.
However, we saw that the results of WinBench 99's Transfer Rate test and HDTach's Sequential read test show lower transfer and read speeds with the Seagate drive compared to the E5. The Disk Access time was also 1.8ms slower than the E5, at 15ms.
The 120GB Seagate drive is geared more towards those who just want to easily add a small amount of disk space to their systems. For daily backups and standard archival, any USB or FireWire based drive is a great addition to your desktop environment and Seagate creates a decent, stackable product with simple features that will appeal to all types of users.
Seagate's other external drives include FireWire and push button backup capabilities with capacities currently up to 400GB. The 120GB version comes at a cost in the sub-$100 range while the 300GB version, which has the Firewire interface along with the USB 2.0 interface, as well as the single button backup, runs between $200-$250 on average at most places. The 320GB E5 is seen as low as $222 at some online retailers and it features both Push Button backup as well as the FireWire 400 interface. Depending on your daily needs, the prices are at about the same level for the drive capacity and features they offer.
Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1802 (Wayback Machine).