Archive 1997–2024

SFF Roundup, Socket 939 Systems

Noise Benchmarks

We used an SPL meter with a sensitivity of down to 30 dB in A-weighted mode to measure noise levels. While it may not be the most realistic placement for the meter, measurements were taken at a distance of 12 inches from the rear of the case. This was necessary to get meaningful differences from the systems in idle mode, though we admit it's not entirely accurate - especially with the fans frequently located at the rear of the case. We also measured from the front-right area of the computer at a range of 48 inches, roughly where we would expect most people to sit in relation to their case. A few of the units were quiet enough that the sensitivity of our SPL device came into play at the larger distance, and while none dropped below 30 dB, accuracy becomes suspect the closer we get to 30 dB. Noise tests were also taken with and without an X800Pro installed; integrated graphics were used if available, or a fanless MX440 or 6600 card was used for the other systems.

System Noise Level

System Noise Level

The maximum noise level measured is a true "worst case" scenario, and the only time that we measured this level of noise was usually during the POST sequence when the CPU and GPU fans spin at maximum RPM. The minimum noise level is the noise level measured while the system sits idle at the Windows desktop. This is the level of noise that you'll most often hear when doing simple business tasks, surfing the internet, or writing email.

System Noise Level

System Noise Level

The stress test measurements were taken while looping 3DMark03 after it had been running for over an hour. At that point, the systems are typically at their maximum temperature levels and the variable speed fans will often become louder and quieter; we record the maximum noise level reached under the stress test, though it's important to remember that often this maximum will only be reached for a few seconds before fan RPMs decrease again.

System Noise Level

System Noise Level

For tests without the X800 Pro, we omitted the stress test and simply report the noise level after the computer has been running for 30 minutes. Room temperature was not consistent, though it was 70 to 75 degrees F so it shouldn't impact the results too much. As you can see, the SN25P and 3901-300P are both much louder than the other units when a fanless GPU isn't present.

The items to which we'd pay the most attention are the idle (minimum) noise levels and the stress test noise levels. If you plan on using a quiet GPU, look at those results as well. All of these systems are very quiet in typical use - even the Soltek is quieter than most desktop ATX cases that have two or more 80mm fans installed. The stress tests make the 330P and SN25P look worse than what they really are, as the peak noise level that we measured at one specific point in the stress test isn't a continual irritant. Most of the time, they run at around 48 to 50 dB and it would only spike up to 53/54 dB periodically (once every couple of minutes). Overall, the G5 units prove the maturity of the design, as they come out as the quietest systems in the stress test and fanless GPU tests.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1754 (Wayback Machine).