Archive 1997–2024

SanDisk Extreme PRO and Crucial X6 4TB Portable SSDs Review: Contrasting High-Capacity Storage Options

Worst-Case Performance Consistency

The performance of the storage bridges / drives in various real-world access traces as well as synthetic workloads was brought out in the preceding sections. We also looked at the performance consistency for these cases. Power users may also be interested in performance consistency under worst-case conditions.

Flash-based storage devices tend to slow down in unpredictable ways when subject to a large number of small-sized random writes. Many benchmarks use that scheme to pre-condition devices prior to the actual testing in order to get a worst-case representative number. Fortunately, such workloads are uncommon for direct-attached storage devices, where workloads are largely sequential in nature. Use of SLC caching as well as firmware caps to prevent overheating may cause drop in write speeds when a flash-based DAS device is subject to sustained sequential writes.

Our Sequential Writes Performance Consistency Test configures the device as a raw physical disk (after deleting configured volumes). A fio workload is set up to write sequential data to the raw drive with a block size of 128K and iodepth of 32 to cover 90% of the drive capacity. The internal temperature is recorded at either end of the workload, while the instantaneous write data rate and cumulative total write data amount are recorded at 1-second intervals.

Sequential Writes to 90% Capacity - Performance Consistency
TOP: BOTTOM:

The SanDisk Extreme PRO v2 4TB maintains peak performance of around 1850 MBps for around 30 seconds before moving down a bit to a respectable 1600 MBps for the rest of the workload. The numbers point to a SLC cache of around 60GB, but the direct TLC write has very goood performance too. The temperature delta between the start and the end was 15C, but the maximum temperature was only 56C pointing to a very effective thermal solution.

The Crucial X6 maintains peak advertised performance of around 780 MBps for more than 16 minutes, pointing to a SLC cache of around 787 GB. However, once the cache runs out, the speeds move down to around 75 MBps till around 1.47TB of total continuous data writes. Beyond that, the speeds go down to around 50 MBps for the rest of the workload. The temperature delta is around 61C, but the slow writes in the latter part of the process means that not much heat gets generated anyway. The thermal solution with the plastic casing for the SSD is acceptable.

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/16892/sandisk-extreme-pro-crucial-x6-4tb-portable-ssds (Wayback Machine).