Archive 1997–2024

Intel Dual Core Performance Preview Part II: A Deeper Look

Gaming Multitasking Scenario 2: DVD Shrink

For our next test, we wanted to do something a little less strenuous, so we only ran one background task: DVD Shrink.  We left DVD Shrink at its default low priority and went ahead with our benchmarks:

Gaming Multitasking Performance Scenario 2

Thanks to DVD Shrink behaving and running with a low priority, our gameplay was largely unaffected on the Athlon 64.  The performance dropped less than 3% in Doom 3. 

What's very interesting, however, is that the Pentium 4 630 takes a huge performance hit with DVD Shrink running in the background.  Despite being set to a low priority, since Hyper Threading allows both the DVD Shrink thread and Doom 3 thread to execute concurrently, they both contend for the same microprocessor execution resources.  This happens to be one case where Hyper Threading is actually very bad for performance, as the OS has no idea that its scheduling is actually hurting the CPU's performance severely. 

Gaming Multitasking Performance Scenario 2

Gaming Multitasking Performance Scenario 2

Gaming Multitasking Performance Scenario 2

The performance gap between the Pentium D and the Athlon 64 actually closes quite a bit under Splinter Cell.  The minimum frame rates are now identical, although the maximum frame rates are clearly higher on the AMD system. 

Once again, HT has a negative impact in this case on the Pentium 4 630. 

Just for kicks, we decided to turn off DVD Shrink's low priority setting to see what impact that would have on performance.  The low priority mode of DVD Shrink basically makes it transparent to gaming.  Unchecking this option definitely changes things, it wouldn't even start on the Athlon 64 system. 

It eventually ran on the Pentium D system after waiting several minutes for it to start, and even then, performance wasn't acceptable.  It just goes to show you that dual core isn't Superman; it does have its limits. 

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1657 (Wayback Machine).