Archive 1997–2024

Intel Xeon 3.6 2MB vs AMD Opteron 252 Database Test


Price comparison & Final Words

In previous articles, we've taken a look at the cost of the processor itself. Since servers aren't just about the processor, we've taken our pricing to an entire platform. We've attempted to spec out Intel and AMD servers from 2 different vendors and have them as close as possible in terms of features. There are obviously a few differences here and there, but as illustrated below, the price difference is negligible between either platform when taking into account the features missing on either platform. Note that we are comparing Dual Intel 3.6 1MB L2 based servers against Dual Opteron 250 servers, since the newer products that we have discussed in this article are not yet in the retail channel.

   HP ProLiant DL360 SCSI  HP ProLiant DL145 SCSI  IBM xSeries 336  IBM eServer 326
Platform Intel AMD Intel AMD
CPU Dual 3.6 GHz 1MB L2 Dual Opteron 250 (2.4GHz) Dual 3.6 Ghz 1MB L2 Dual Opteron 250 (2.4 GHz)
Memory 2GB 2GB 2GB 2GB
Hard Drive 36.4 Pluggable Ultra320 (15,000 RPM) 36.4 Non Pluggable Ultra320 (15,000 RPM) IBM 36GB 2.5" 10K SCSI HDD HS 36GB 10K U320 SCSI HS Option
SCSI Controller Smart Array 6i Plus controller (onboard) Dual Channel Ultra 320 SCSI HBA Integrated Single-Channel Ultra320 SCSI Controller (Standard) Integrated Single-Channel Ultra320 SCSI Controller (Standard)
Bays Two Ultra 320 SCSI Hot Plug Drive Bays Two non-hot plug hard drive bays 4 hot swap bays 2 hot swap bays
Network NC7782 PCI-X Gigabit NICs (embedded) Broadcom 5704 Gigabit Nics (embedded) Dual integrated 10/100/1000 Mbps Ethernet (Standard) Dual integrated 10/100/1000 Mbps Ethernet (Standard)
Power 460W hot pluggable power supply 500W non hot plug power supply 585W power supply 411W Power Supply (Standard)
Server Management SmartStart & Insight Manager None System Management Processor (Standard) System Management Processor (Standard)
OS None None None None
Cost $5,946 $5,009 $5,476 $5,226

Final words

We've illustrated how workload has a significant effect on platform decision when it comes to database servers. Obviously, for a small to medium business, where there are multiple different workloads being run on the same server, the decision to go with a platform architecture best suited for Data warehousing alone doesn't make sense. But for larger organizations where multiple database servers are used, each having a specific purpose, the decision to go with one platform or another could have a significant impact on performance. For dual-processor applications, Intel leads the way in everyday small to heavy transactional applications, whereas AMD shines in the analytical side of database applications "Data Warehousing".

These results do raise some questions as to what is going on exactly during each test at an architectural level. Is the processor waiting for data from the L2 cache? Is the processor branch prediction units not suited for this particular workload? Is there a bottleneck with memory latency? We want these questions answered, and are going to investigate ways to provide concrete answers to these tough questions in the future.


Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1615 (Wayback Machine).