Archive 1997–2024

Half Life 2 GPU Roundup Part 1 - DirectX 9 Shootout

Head to Head: ATI Radeon X700 XT vs. NVIDIA GeForce 6600GT

As far as PCI Express platforms go, the Radeon X700 XT and the GeForce 6600GT are about as evenly matched as you can get in terms of price and performance and thankfully they are both readily available today. Let's see how they perform head to head under Half Life 2:

In our first demo, the two basically tie - we aren't considering performance differences of ~3% or less to be anything significant.

Half Life 2 AT_canals_08.dem
 
ATI Radeon X700 XT
NVIDIA GeForce 6600GT
Performance Advantage
1024 x 768
116.4
113.5
2.6%
1280 x 1024
78.7
78.1
0.8%
1600 x 1200
55.9
57.7
3.1%
1024 x 768 - 4X AA
75.3
72.7
3.6%
Winner
-
-
Tie

Our second demo shows the X700 XT pulling ahead and definitely taking the lead when AA is enabled.

Half Life 2 AT_coast_05.dem
 
ATI Radeon X700 XT
NVIDIA GeForce 6600GT
Performance Advantage
1024 x 768
133.5
129.6
3.0%
1280 x 1024
112.3
107.9
4.1%
1600 x 1200
81.9
78.5
4.3%
1024 x 768 - 4X AA
115.8
107.2
8.0%
Winner
-
-
X700 XT

We have a tie once again in our third demo:

Half Life 2 AT_coast_12.dem
 
ATI Radeon X700 XT
NVIDIA GeForce 6600GT
Performance Advantage
1024 x 768
115.7
113.6
1.8%
1280 x 1024
88
88.2
0.2%
1600 x 1200
63
64.4
2.2%
1024 x 768 - 4X AA
87.5
87.1
0.5%
Winner
-
-
Tie

Our fourth demo shows the X700 XT pulling far ahead with AA enabled, but otherwise the two perform identically:

Half Life 2 AT_prison_05.dem
 
ATI Radeon X700 XT
NVIDIA GeForce 6600GT
Performance Advantage
1024 x 768
119
116.1
2.5%
1280 x 1024
79.4
77.2
2.8%
1600 x 1200
55.5
55.7
0.4%
1024 x 768 - 4X AA
85.1
74.6
14.1%
Winner
-
-
X700 XT

In our final demothe X700 XT manages to maintain the greatest performance advantage, even at 1600 x 1200 without AA the X700 XT is over 10% faster than the 6600GT.

Half Life 2 AT_c17_12.dem
 
ATI Radeon X700 XT
NVIDIA GeForce 6600GT
Performance Advantage
1024 x 768
87.3
82.9
5.3%
1280 x 1024
82.2
76.4
7.6%
1600 x 1200
69.2
61.6
12.3%
1024 x 768 - 4X AA
77.4
70
10.6%
Winner
-
-
X700 XT

We averaged all of the X700 XT's wins together to make up the table below. From the looks of it, the X700 XT is significantly faster when AA is enabled, but is otherwise a relative equal to the 6600GT. What is important to note here is that the sweet spot for image quality and performance on these two cards appears to be at 1280 x 1024, where they are both virtually equal in performance.

Summary
 
Average Performance Advantage (X700 XT over 6600GT)
1024 x 768
3.0%
1280 x 1024
3.1%
1600 x 1200
4.5%
1024 x 768 - 4X AA
7.3%

Originally published at https://www.anandtech.com/show/1546 (Wayback Machine).